Stephen Moffat stepping down (as of 2017) as showrunner of Doctor Who isn't that much of a surprise; he's had a long run, and while back during season 7 I felt he should have finished then, I'm really glad he didn't, because the Capaldi era felt revitalized and turned into my favourite part of his tenure.

The news that Chris Chibnall will take over, otoh, is something that leaves me with mixed emotions. A couple of years ago I would have been horrified, because I really disliked Chibnall's early Torchwood and early Doctor Who episodes. Otoh, not only did I like Torchwood's second season (which he did head), I also liked both his s2 opener, complete with old lady exclaiming "Bloody Torchwood!", and Adrift. And I really was impressed by by Broadchurch, season 1, which was all Chibnall, all the time, to give credit where due. (Otoh, Broadchurch, season 2, also all Chibnall, etc., was, err, where I quit watching, though mostly because making a story with a clear ending go on just because it had been that successful was exactly the bad idea you'd think it would be.) So basically: his DW era could be terrible, could be good, will probably be some of both.

However, one thing I can already predict: we'll get yet more rounds of "OMG this show runner so misogynist!" "But last showrunner so misogynist!" "How can you critique old/new showrunner for such and such when you liked new/old show runner's display of that and this!" "Fandom is so unfair to new showrunner while being blind to old show runner's flaws!" "Are you kidding? During old showrunner's tenure, the wanky complaints were endless, and now you're surprised new showrunner is in for some entirely reasonable criticism?" (Seriously, the way some Moffat-only and RTD-only fans seem to think that THEIR guy got all the fannish bile while the other guy had never been given that treatment baffles me. Of course, if you ever bring that up, you only hear "but it was totally justified in the case of X! Who still didn't get nearly the amount which Y was getting!" (Oh yes he did. Just from other people. Mostly.)


(And then there will be those who have hated on the previous two and will hate on the new one with equal ferveour, because that's fandom.)

Incidentally, I do hope Chibnall will write Olivia Coleman a role in DW, because Ellie (her detective on Broadchurch) is amazing, and he's that kind of crossover producer (as evidenced by the fact Broadchurch not only had David Tennant as the other lead but Arthur "Rory" Darvill in a key supporting role, and in s2 Eve Myles in a supporting role as well. AI definitely hope for some married couples, because Chibnall is good at established couples, their arguments, and their bond. As evidenced by both the Gwen and Rhys relationship on TW and the Latimers on Broadchurch.

Meanwhile, no Twelfth Doctor in 2016 until the next Christmas Special? Now THAT'S awful news. Rusty at least gave us an Easter special, Moff, when he was in a comparable situation. Come on.
Necesssary preamble: all of this is extremely subjective. What looks like a good arc for me doesn't have to look like one for you, ditto for chemistry being in the eye of the beholder, etc. And nothing is meant as a disparagement of your own favourites, choices, etc.

Vague spoilers for both DW tv series and Big Finish audios )

The other days
Which was great fun, with just the one touch of sadness necessary given the main characters and their history (and future). It just might displace The Runaway Bride as my favourite Christmas Special so far. It definitely overtook The Last Christmas from last year, though I had liked that a lot, and all the others, both Moffat and RTD era, with ease.

Men always believe stories in which they're the hero )

In conclusion: loved it unreservedly.
1. Your main fandom of the year?

I remain a multifandom woman. This year I said goodbye to some of my favourite shows, found several news ones , and maintained old attachments. Perhaps The Americans was one where I joined in the most discussions?


2. Your favourite film watched this year?

Der Staat gegen Fritz Bauer ("The People vs Fritz Bauer"), about an amazing rl person, Fritz Bauer, German-Jewish, Social Democrat, gay, tries to get justice done against Nazis in 1950s and 1960s Germany where everyone is still in denial mode, and being gay is still illegal. Burkhart Klaußner is amazing in the title role. (And the movie is gutsy enough to open with a tv clip showing the real Fritz Bauer before we get introduced to Klaußner in the role, and there's no suspension of disbelief necessary.


3. Your favourite book read this year?

I did a lot of rereading of old favourites this year, but leaving those aside, probably Wind Raker, the fourth volume in the "Order of the Air" series by Jo Graham and Melissa Scott. This time, our heroes tackle archaeology, mystical dark forces and real life politics in Hawaii.


4. Your favourite TV show of the year?

Difficult to choose. The one which most surprised me by how much I fell in love with it was Better Call Saul. Because I had started to watch it solely because of the earned trust in the creative team from Breaking Bad; I didn't exactly burn with curiosity about Saul Goodman's origin story, Saul Goodman having been an amusing comic relief character in BB about whom I had no strong feelings one way or the other. But lo and behold, did I ever develop strong feelings for Jimmy McGill. Who is still funny (they'd never waste Bob Odenkirk's comedic talents), but also absolutely heartbreaking and incredibly endearing. And I like the ensemble, and the various complex relationships - Jimmy and Chuck, Jimmy and Kim (LOVE Kim, especially), Jimmy and Howard Hamlin, and, as a work in progress, Jimmy and Mike.

Now both Agent Carter and Jessica Jones I had hoped and expected to love (both the shows and the title characters), and so I did, so there wasn't the same element of surprise involved. The Americans had a painfully good third season and continues to feed my rage and award juries which ignore it. Bates Motel: ditto. Elementary gave me a great third season and while I'm not yet feeling the same level in the fourth, it still provides me with enough so I continue to love it. Doctor Who, after a lull in my fannish investment during the Eleventh Doctor era, made me fall for the Twelth Doctor, Clara Oswald and friends (and foes) all over again.

But really, in terms of "When did fondness become love? I must convert more people to watch this show, let me write that manifesto!", there can be only one choice: Black Sails. Dammit, pirates, how could I fall for you so hard!


5. Your favourite online fandom community of the year?

[community profile] theamericans, which I've shamefully neglected in recent months due to various matters. Must become better again when the new season starts!


6. Your best new fandom discovery of the year?

Black Sails I started last year, and Agent Carter and Jessica Jones weren't exactly new discoveries because I knew some of the characters of the former already via the MCU, and was familiar with the source material of the later. Better Call Saul was a spin-off from a show I was familiar with. So I shall look to one of my oldest fandoms, historical novels, and nominate [profile] sonetka's wonderful website with its witty and thorough overview of novels starring Anne Boleyn, The head that launched a thousand books.

7. Your biggest fandom disappointment of the year?

Once upon a Time, season 4, rivals with The Good Wife, season 6, for the title; The Good Wife wins, barely. I drew the consequences and quit both shows.


8. Your TV boyfriend of the year?

There are about a million reasons why dating Saul Goodman would be a bad idea, but Jimmy McGill, post-Slippin Jimmy, pre-Saul days? In a heartbeat. He's a movie buff, he's funny, he's kind, and he'd even into providing free pedicure for the work stressed woman.

9. Your TV girlfriend of the year?

Peggy Carter. Me and a million other people. But: Peggy! She's ultra competent, she's loyal, she has the art of sarcasm down to a t, she can love deeply without becoming all about one person, instead valuing other relationships as well, and she's gorgeous.

10. Your biggest squee moment of the year?

Norma Bates invites family and friends for supper in 3.07, ominously titled The Last Supper. But in fact it's as fluffy as any scene on this show could get... considering that two characters at the table have deeply traumatic rape history (with each other), another character is a budding serial killer, another is a corrupt cop, one is a profession drug smuggler with gigantic mommy issues, one is Norma Bates who is, well, Norma, and the only nonviolent, non-traumatized, non-trauma causing, nice and normal person on the table, Emma, has an illness which condems her to die in her 20s. And yet this manages to be an absolutely heartwarming, squee worthy moment. This show, I tell you.


11. The most missed of your old fandoms?

The Babylon 5 community has started a series review, but I just don't have the time right now. The recent silly (nothing wrong with that, but it was) trailer for the next Star Trek Reboot movie also made me nostalgic for my Trek, and for ye olde days of discussing DS9 episodes and themes at [profile] ds9agogo.

12. The fandom you haven’t tried yet, but want to?

I'm currently eying How to get away with Murder. Maybe I'll also dare the Hamilton juggernaut.

13. Your biggest fan anticipations for the New Year?

Bryan Fuller's version of American Gods, based on Neil Gaiman's novel (which I love). Season 2 of Agent Carter, season 4 of The Americans, season 3 of Black Sails, season 4 of Bates Motel (definitely); season 2 of Better Call Saul (hopefully).
selenak: (Equations by Such_Heights)
( Dec. 8th, 2015 08:50 pm)
'Ts the season to be sappy, even for noir detectives with backstory trauma, therefore, have this Jessica Jones post season 1 tale of Malcolm determined to spread some Christmas spirit to Jessica (and Robyn):

It's beginning to look a lot like Christmas

Doctor Who:

Why Peter Capaldi is the Über Doctor: not sure I agree re: the previous ones not deliberately echoing predecessors, but it's still a neat appraisal.

And lastly, a non-fannish tale:


Svetlana Alexejievich's Novel Prize lecture: impressive, like the woman's books.
Honestly, I have no idea yet how I feel about all of this. There's probably somewhwere some great meta to be written about all echoing and contrasting and deconstructing and reconstructing of Previous Events (particularly two from the RTD era, but by no means exclusively; Moffat's own stuff comes heavily in for it as well, plus some Old Who tropes and the TV Movie Of Doom, oh, and the Big Finish canon, too). But I'm not up for writing said meta yet (horribly real life business!), so just a few impressions, as per usual. For the most part, it emotionally worked for me... I think.

Read more... )
The one wherein the Moff shows he REALLY trusts his leading actor. A lot.
Bird! )
Above cut unspoilery comment: a new scriptwriter, a new female scriptwriter, and one whom as opposed to Catherine Tregenna I don't recall writing for either DW or Torchwood before, though I may have missed something: welcome, Sarah Dollard! And an excellent episode, too, which was good not just because it needed to be, given one point of the content, but because of the Mark Gatiss penned rubbish last week having followed the "loved some parts, hated others" Zygon two parter. I was more than ready for an episode I could value completely again.

All other emotional reactions would be spoilerly, and hence they go beneath a cut. )
I was very RL busy these last view days, which included travelling and limited internet access. And then Paris happened, about which no adequate thing can be said. For all these reasons as well as the actual content, the following two reviews are a bit on the terse side.

Elementary 4.02.: Meh. Read more... )

Doctor Who 9.06: The first standalone episode this season. Penned by Mark Gatiss, feeling very much like Gattis trying to write a Moffat type standalone ep and failing, and it makes me mumble what I nearly always do with Gatiss written episodes (there are two or so exceptions): please, please, please, stick to acting. I really like you as an actor. As a writer... sigh. Read more... )
The first one written by Peter Harness, the second by Peter Harness and Stephen Moffat. Now that the two parter is complete, I think....

Read more... )

So basically: this was the two parter of very mixed feelings for me, and by this I don't mean a case of "hm" but a case of "I hate this" and "I love this" both.
selenak: (Bardolatry by Cheesygirl)
( Nov. 1st, 2015 09:36 am)
No Doctor Who review this week, because it's another two parter, and in this case what I think of it REALLY depends on what the solution will be, because the allegory is really heavy handed and potentially disastrous.

However, last night I watched the latest cinematic version of the Scottish Play, aka the one with Michael Fassbender and Marion Cotillard.

Thoughts: overall, this strikes me as director Justin Kurzel's GrimDark Shakespeare fanfiction, err, vid. Not that Macbeth is a bundle of laughs in any case, and any screen Shakespeare ends up having lots of lines cut (unless it's Kenneth Branagh wanting to make a point about Hamlet), but not so coincidentally, this Macbeth is lacking any and all of what few lighter moments there are. Which means no porter scene at all, no precocious Macduff kids chattering away before doom arrives. Considering the porter scene in particular is always held up as evidence of Shakespeare being a genius (i.e. it's the most suspenseful, tense moment of the play, Macbeth has just committed regicide, there's KNOCKING, and suddenly! Drunk Comedy Scene!), this tells you something about Kurzel (and his scriptwriter team's) idea of how to do drama versus good old Will's.

Otoh team Kurzel even added to the body count, ways of execution and motivation. The opening scene is a funeral for the Macbeths' child (thereby solving ye olde contradiction between "I have given suck" and "he has no children" in ways that doesn't evoke actual history, where historical Lady Macbeth, Gruach, had a child by her first marriage), watched over by the witches who speak a few lines from the play's opening scene, and the implication that losing their child is partly what motivates the Macbeths and already started to unhinge them is there through the rest of the movie. The opening funeral scene later is doubled, and this one goes beneath a spoiler cut because it's in the last third, Kurzel-only, and maybe someone does care to be spoilered. How Kurzel explains Lady Macbeth losing it completely. )

Speaking of history, though, the movie attempts to go for a "primitive Scotland" atmosphere by excising any and all contemporary to Shakespeare stuff. Except for the royal castle in the second half of the movie, there aren't any castles at all, Macbeth while he's still a thane has a settlement of wooden huts/houses. (Lady M's reference to "my battlements" is duly gone as well.) No dialogue between the Doctor and the Not!Lady in waiting (who is reduced to a silent female companion of the queen's). Oh, and (entirely correctly) no kilts, in case you feared there were. Though everyone but Cotillard goes for a Scottish accent, which is wavering in Fassbender's case, though the rest is more steadfast.

Acting: Fassbender does his thing of intense brooding with undercurrent of emotional turnmoil, which he does as easily as breathing, but because that's already how he STARTS, there isn't much of an emotional arc. Also the film is the type of Macbeth production which actually visualizes M's hallucinations. (I've seen productions where the dead Banquo actually shows up, and productions where he doesn't, and let me tell you, the later always worked better for me. And showing the dagger Macbeth imagines never is as good as relying on your leading man, not to mention it patronizes the audience.) Marion Cottillard isn't as hard as she could be early on, nor really insane and in pieces later. She doesn't sleepwalk, she returns to what used to be the Glamis estate and speaks all the lines of the sleepwalking scene awake as if musing about her past, until the camera reveals that spoiler cut just in case. ) In a movie that's GRIM with capital letters, it comes across as an odd restraint or maybe as the wish to keep your leading lady sympathetic.

Another thing: this is a movie with a fondness for male cheek touching, forehead touching, and men cradling each other. When the messengers arrive with news for Macbeth and Banquo, Macbeth is busy cradling a fellow warrior whom Banquo patches up. Duncan cradles Macbeth's cheek (and before that of the rebellious previous thane of Cawdor while pronouncing sentence on him), Macbeth and Banquo do it to each other, Macbeth holds the slain Duncan and so forth. You get the impression someone really really liked both the "I know it was you!" scene between Michael and Fredo from Godfather II and Craig!Bond's thing for cradling people ('Vesper, Mathis, M) a lot. Or, to put my highbrow hat on, Kurzel is going for a correlation between death and physical expression of affection. (Not surprisingly, the Macbeths end up having sex while conspiring Duncan's murder.)

Influences of previous film versions: Polanski for the final twist. No, it's not Ross as in Polanski, but Fleance, but the implication is the same. (And presumably Team Wurzel wanted to tie up the Witches' prophecy re: Banquo's issue, presumably correctly assuming that most of their target audience don't know Banquo's issue were meant to be the Stuart dynasty.) The famous 1970s Trevor Nunn production (that starred Judi Dench and Ian McKellen and still is my favourite of the play) for individualizing the Witches and going for mother-maiden-crone, though Wurzel also adds a silent child witch and a baby for good measure.

Unholy influence of Zack Snyder: slo mo and frozen battle scenes and key points intercut by fast moving ones.

Trivia: you know, Tolkien came up with the Ents because as a boy he was disappointed when the "when Birnham Wood comes up to Dunsinane" prophecy didn't get fulfilled by the trees literally moving towards Dunsinane? Tolkien would have been horrified by Wurzels innovation on how the prophecy gets fulfilled, but it makes for the showdown visual he wants. Spoilery explanation why. )

In conclusion: not a must among Shakespeare film versions, and I've watched both Fassbender and Cotillard doing better, but it should provide a lot of vid makers with material.
Darth Real Life keeps me relentlessly busy these days, but I had to share this thing of joy which [personal profile] andraste provided me with:

An episode which I loved despite there hardly being any Clara in it. (This obviously was the annual Companion-lite episode, which makes me wonder whether the next one will be the Doctor-lite ep.) Also, before I get to the actual content, an embarrassing (for the BBC) drumroll for the fact that Catherine Treganna, who wrote some of the best Torchwood episodes (Out of Time and Captain Jack Harkness in season 1, Meat and Adam in season 2), with this episode becomes the first female scriptwriter in the Moffat era. (The RTD era wasn't exactly stellar re: female scriptwriters, either, but Rusty did have Helen Raynor on DW and both Catherine Treganna and Helen Raynor on Torchwood.) Before I saw Catherine Treganna's name, I hadn't known she's written for this season, since I try to stay spoiler free in all regards and thus avoid the publicity. It was a very welcome surprise and a very fitting assignment, given the obvious thematic parallels between this episode and especially Out of Time. And a last above cut remark: Maisie Williams really rose to the task of her character, which was a different one than last episode.

Read more... )
selenak: (Tourists by Kathyh)
( Oct. 19th, 2015 06:54 pm)
Back from Frankfurt Book Fair, barely, totally wrung out, hence briefly some impressions of the episode in which the Doctor and Clara meet Arya Stark a girl.

Read more... )
selenak: (Boozing it up)
( Oct. 11th, 2015 05:53 pm)
Part two of the unexpected two parter.

Read more... )
Toby Whithouse! You're back - and despite the occasional objection to some of your Being Human narrative decisions, still my candidate from the currently involved writers to take over from Moffat. BH icon used in your honor.

Read more... )
In which glasses are cool. :)

Read more... )
selenak: (Ten and Donna by Trolliepop)
( Sep. 25th, 2015 10:50 am)
This already made my day: Big Finish, having at last secured the rights to New Who characters as well, will give us more Donna and Tenth Doctor adventures. My absolutely favourite Doctor and Companion combination from the New Who era returns! More magical Tate & Tennant banter: these two had such superb comic timing together, even off screen when they did radio interviews, so I'm pretty confident Ten and Donna will translate well to the audio format.

In conclusion: I'm a happy, happy Doctor Who fan this morning. YES!
I'm all conferenced out; yesterday was the last day, and in the evening I had the chance to catch the Doctor Who season premiere on BBC America. Since my head still half crowded with academia and the transatlantic sense of being out of time hasn't abated yet (and won't have a chance to, since I'm flying back today), I'm feeling a bit groggy, so excuse any incoherence or inconclusiveness.

Spoiler realise a Big Finish audio has just gotten jossed )
.

Profile

selenak: (Default)
selenak

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags