Obsession by Eirena
( Feb. 20th, 2010 03:03 pm)
Star Trek:

The Dance. Fantastic story about Gaila, with fabulous world-building around all things Orion. I love with when fanfic writers take all the various and contradictory bits canon has on an alien culture and weave them into a cohorent hole!

Alias:

You know, I love the new AO3 archive, I really do. Those tags are neat. Of course, sometimes they provide frustration (as in: "still nobody but me writes Abigail Brand? Damm. Wait! [personal profile] crossedwires has posted her stories with Brand in them as well, hooray! But I already knew them. Why not more Brand love, fandom?"), but sometimes they are rewarding. As in: "hooray, more stories with Arvin Sloane in them! And some of them I didn't know before." This one, by [profile] nomadicwriter, is actually an ensemble story, or collection of drabbles weaving a whole, if you like, covering the entire run of the show (and before), and that messy, fascinating tangled web of relationships between the Bristows, Arvin Sloane and the Derevkos:

Permutations
List five characters you'd want on your side in any kind of trouble. Bonus points for assembling an "Action Team" with complementary skills.

Ohhh, unfair requirement. Any kind of trouble? The team for the zombie apocalypse is significantly different from the one for epic showdowns with the taxman is significantly different from the one when I sob my heart out in the hypothetical case of it being broken is different from when my latest working effort is not appreciated. Etc. Take Jack Bristow (Alias), for example. Provided you are on the same side his daughter is on, he's ideal for anything from secret spying missions to zombie apocalypse. Is bound to intimidate accountants, too, and has experience in hiding money. Clever, ruthless, yet not a supervillain. Can even provide babysitters with shooting skills. But you do NOT want Jack Bristow with you if your favourite show just got cancelled and you want to grouse for hours about how unfair this was. Or your beloved character has been given the wrong story arc. And you definitely do not want him with you if you have a moral crisis and wonder what the right thing to do is. No way.

It goes without saying that I would stay the hell awy from a lot of the shady characters I love to bits in fiction even when times are good, let alone in times of trouble. A lot of them would sacrifice me to the trouble without blinking. And then there are some beloved heroes who have a way of getting their entourage killed, so I don't want them around, either.

Looking out for competence in action scenarios, in handholding and in finances, and reliability instead of sacrificing me to the cause, here's the team I came up with:

1.) Martha Jones (Doctor Who). Has proven survival skills in apocalyptic scenarios, is smart and well-read, so there'd be a lot to talk about, has had aftermaths of emotional catastrophes thrown at her and dealt with same, and is a medical doctor, which is always useful. So no matter what kind of trouble I'm in, I want Martha at my side.

2.) Jadzia Dax (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine). Smart, centuries old, great sense of humour, can fight (both old fashioned hand to hand combat or sci fi weapons) if that's required but also provide factual knowledge and/or emotional insight if that is the nature of the trouble. Also, she's great friends with Quark which could be helpful in the catastrophe is financial in nature.

3.) Vir Cotto (Babylon 5). Vir is sweet-natured, loyal to a fault, one of the quiet ones bad guys usually overlook (to their detriment), in possession of both strong ethics and joie de vivre. No one's candidate for a bodyguard, but that's what other team members are for. He's there for moral support and/or reminders of what's really important/ which methods are justifiable and which aren't, and also for the hugs. And he does know how to keep a secret.

4.) Hugo "Hurley" Reyes (Lost). Like Vir, a genuinenly kind person, very huggable and good at hugging, with proven survival and team-building skills in apocalyptic situations. Very much a geek, which means he could empathize about characters and storyarcs to complain/praise/sob about like no one's business. Even has experience with money.

5.) Zoe Washburne (Firefly). Great fighting skills, deadpan sense of humour, stoic nature. Can survive anything. Due to her marital history, she would not mind me freaking out about spoilers for a show I'm trying to remain unspoiled for or the latest fannish kerfuffle; she has learned to tolerate such things. But her lethal talent of making a few syllables (or one, like "sir") sound sarcastic as hell would make me reign in my flailing, and get a hold on myself, so if the trouble I'm in isn't apocalyptic but fannish in nature, Zoe would be great to have at my side as well.
I'm in London for a few days for work-related reasons, which means a busy schedule, but every now and then I add non-work perks. Yesterday I arrived in time to still get a ticket for Six Degrees of Separation, starring, among others, Anthony Head, Stephen Greif and Stephen Pacey, so it was quite the genre event for a Buffy and Blake's 7 fan like me. :) I was very amused by the way these actors handled their credits in the program. Stephen Pacey, who played Tarrant in B7's third and fourth seaosn, didn't mention Blake's 7 at all, just as Josette Simon (who played Dayna; it was, I think, in fact her first tv job) had excluded it from her credits when I saw her in a RSC production of A Midsummer Night's Dream ages ago. On the other hand, Stephen Greif (Travis I), who was "only" around for one season, had no problem listing it. And Anthony Head gave his most famous role a place of honour. "Television includes NYPD Blue, Spooks, Doctor Who, My Family, The Invisibles, Little Britain, Manchild, Free Agents and Merlin. Anthony appeared as Rupert Giles in Buffy The Vampire Slayer, a critically acclaimed US series." Go, ASH!

The play itself I had seen about fifteen years ago in Los Angeles, but I had forgotten a lot about it, so I didn't import any biases based on other actors. Oli Abili, who plays the central role of Paul, a young conman passing himself off as Sidney Poitier's son to a rich New York couple, pulled off the charm and sincerity splendidly which are necessary so the whole thing remains plausible, and Lesley Manville, playing Ouisa, has the big emotional outburst/revelation near the end which makes the play from mostly satire to character drama and was excellent in it. As was everyone else. It was weird though to hear Anthony Head going for a New York accent, let me tell you that. He was good in his part, btw, as a man who once upon a time used to be passionate about art but has become hollow and only about the money, in his way as much a conman as Paul is, but as for American accents by British actors, I thought Stephen Greif beat him in the convincing department, fair and square.

In other news, during my flight here I read Una MacCormack's The Never-Ending Sacrifice, a Star Trek: Deep Space Nine novel which manages to be at once a media tie-in (it picks up the story of a one-shot character introduced in the second season episode Cardassians and a standalone work with incredible resonance if you have any interest at all in characters between two worlds and cultures, or stories of survivors of catastrophes for whom the euphemism "collateral damage" is all too often used. Her Rugal is a very engaging character, and she never comes up with any pat answers for him; the cameos of familiar DS9 characters like Tekeny Ghemor, Ziyal and of course Garak are great, but I found myself even more captured by her OCs and near-OCs, like Rugal's grandmother (who is a Cardassian version of Livia Drusilla if there ever was one) and his biological father, Kotan, and the painful, intense relationships between these three. Highly recommended
Illyria by Kathyh
( Jan. 23rd, 2010 12:48 pm)
Star Trek:

Five Decisions Winona Made For Her Family: in which reboot!verse Winona Kirk is fleshed out magnificently. I love it when fanfiction does that.

Doctor Who:

A lovely Sarah Jane Smith vid, portraying her from her companion days to her SJA glory.

Buffy:

The Last Fingers of Leaf: awesome post-show encounter between Buffy, Illyria and a dragon in Rome.

Merlin:

Stay: a very engaging story about Gwen and Arthur, Gwen pov.
Rejected out of hand are such death traps as Angel Investigations, Torchwood, or secret sections of the FBI or CIA, I'll have you know. Also, regretfully, Joe's bar from Highlander, because gratis concerts aside, I always was bad at maths and would make a lousy waitress. Also the Miami police, because clearly there are far too many serial killers in Miami. They could start a convention. On that note, here are five candidates with reasonable survival chances:


1.) The Library of Dreams. Sandman. Come on. Not only every book ever written, but every book any author has ever dreamt of writing but somehow didn't get around to. Clearly, Lucien has the best job ever. Granted, working for Dream has its downsides, as when he's kidnapped for 70 plus years or when the Furies are after him, but that happens rarely enough not to affect my wish for long term employment.

2.) The Daily Planet. (Lois & Clark incarnation of same.) A newspaper with an Elvis-loving chief editor and hot reporters is clearly the place to intern or get hired as columnist/foreign correspondant. Even if a supervillain occasionally tries to buy it.

3.) The Enterprise - D. (Star Trek: The Next Generation). Allows families and pets on board along with the space exploration, as opposed to the original Enterprise, which as I'm not sure I want to spend the rest of my life single sounds like an advantage, plus, really, whose voice would you want to hear on a daily basis announcing every day ship business, Kirk's or Picard's? Also, the holodeck. Barclay and I would probably swap therapy stories.

4.) The Bartlet White House. (The West Wing). No idea whether I could keep up with the speed of the conversations, or what exactly I would do there, but it would appeal to my inner idealist.

5.) The Herald. (State of Play, original tv version.) Another newspaper with a snarky chief editor and hot reporters. Being located in London, which means better theatre and bookstore options for me (sorry, Metropolis). I would so work there.
Due to James Cameron's Avatar - which btw I have not watched, and thus do not feel qualified to discuss -, there was a lot of talk about the "White Messiah" motif in both online and newspaper reviews recently. Which among other things made me realise something: DS9 really lucked out with the fact that Sisko is played by a black actor and the Bajorans by white actors, didn't it? (Apologies if I forgot Bajorans played by black or Asian actors, but without checking old episodes, I don't think there were any. As opposed to the Klingons, who were mainly played by black actors, and of course post-TOS we got black Vulcans as well.) Because otherwise, hm. Let's check.

In a spoilery for all of DS9 fashion. )
Tags:
Live long and prosper by elf of doriath
( Jan. 18th, 2010 03:43 pm)
This one is filled with so much love for both new and old canon, using Spock's journey as the red thread of deaths, births and rebirths:

Grapevine Fires

As with the best stories and vids, this one will probably affect you differently depending on what embodies ST most for you, and there are so many different aspects of it to treasure. Spoilery praise follows. )
Fannish5: Name five characters who should have their own spinoffs.

The interesting thing about this question is that it's not the same as asking for favourite supporting or recurring characters in already existing shows. For example, back in ye olde Highlander days I was among the few who loved Methos as a character but did not root for a Methos spin-off. Why not? Because Methos thrives on being a trickster character, whose loyalties can't be a 100% guaranteed even if he's a friend, and whose background is party a mystery to the other characters and the viewer, revealed only in parts. He also thrives on being played off against a straight lead. If there had been a Methos spin-off, Methos would inevitably have been written more like a conventional hero, would have lost his unpredictability, and thus some of his allure. Which is why I never thought he was suitable for one. He was a born guest character. So, let's see, characters who would and could carry spin-offs of their own without losing the elements that made them attractive in the first place:

1.) Alastair Gordon Lethbridge-Stewart, in short: the Brig(adier), from Doctor Who. It's impossible now, of course, and I know there were some UNIT audios, but what I'm talking about is a UNIT spin-off from Doctor Who during the later 70s, after Four gallivanted off to tour the cosmos again, with the Brig as the lead. He could have tried to get Liz Shaw back as scientific advisor, and there could have been UST; lingering betrayal issues with Mike Yates; the ever reliable Benton; and some new characters the audience wasn't familiar with. (As much as I've become fond of Torchwood in its second season and love, love, love Children of Earth, I still think it's somehow unfair Jack Harkness got a spin-off and the Brig did not.

2.) Lady Johanna Constantine, originally of Sandman. She actually did get a one-shot spin-off, and I loved it, but I'm talking about a full-fledged comic series here. She's a female adventurer living in the late 18th and through to the mid 19th century - that has so much potential, for so many stories.

3.) Chiana, from Farscape. The Nebari and their completely screwed up political system pretty much were ignored post s2, and the show never could make up its mind on what exactly Chiana's post-s3-accident powers were. And she's a vivid, entertaining character who has grown up through Farscape. In short, there is much story telling potential for a spin-off in which she's the lead and forced to deal with the home she's been running from, and her lost brother.

4.) Alias Linus and Farrad is my Lost spin-off of choice, by which I mean: spoilery things for s4 and 5 of Lost ). It's worth at least a miniseries of its own, surely!

5.) Number One and Christopher Pike from Star Trek. This is probably my geekiest choice. They would have been the leads of Star Trek if the original pilot had been accepted. Which it was not, and thus Kirk became Captain of the Enterprise. Now we've got a reboot which is simultanously a legitimate AU, and we've got a new Pike who completely hit my soft spot for smart middle-aged men and must not be allowed to sink into obscurity again. Why not also give us a reboot!Number One, the female first officer audiences weren't ready to accept in the 1960s, and give her and Pike a spin-off of their own while the kids are having the big screen adventures? (Someone suggested Jennifer Garner for Number One - and also for Christine Chapel, should she be used in rebooted Trek, as both roles were originally played by Majel Barret - and I'm so enamored with that idea, I can't tell you.)


Fanfiction and vid recs, all Doctor Who:

Two lovely and amusing snapshots of my favourite New Who TARDIS team, Donna and the Tenth Doctor, set during s4:

Fair Trade: in which Donna breaks him out of prison.

Glossolia: in which they end up somewhere where the TARDIS can't translate.

Vid:

Run : "There is an awful lot of running involved" in the Doctor's existence, as Donna put it. Indeed. Fast-paced, simultanously a character portrait of the Doctor and a homage to the era with a Masterly bias, just wonderful to watch.
1. Your main fandom of the year?

I remained a committed multifandom girl.

2. Your favorite film watched this year?

It's a tie between Star Trek XI, for the sheer nostalgic fun of it and the new cast gaining my affection on their own, and Milk, which was both a good film based on real characters and a cinematic expression of the romance of political activism. If pressed, I'd pick Milk, though.


3. Your favorite book read this year?

The Graveyard Book by Neil Gaiman, hands down.

4. Your favorite album or song to listen to this year?

There was that band from Liverpool whom you might have heard of, and whose entire ouevre went out on CD again. I think my overall favourite Beatles album is probably Revolver, but this year I listened to Rubber Soul a lot. Especially Norwegian Wood and In My Life on it.

5. Your favorite TV show of the year?

Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles. So very, very, very good. Favourite tv event of the year, which is not quite the same thing, was Torchwood: Children of Earth, hands down. Some of the best tv I've seen in years, and who'd have thought that, as Paul Cornell memorably put it, "this hard beast grew out of the corpse of dear old campy slash fiction Torchwood"?

6. Your favorite LJ community of the year?

B5_revisited. It's great fun to discuss the old episodes on a weekly basis, though we seem to be on Christmas hiatus right now. What's up with that, [personal profile] ruuger?

7. Your best new fandom discovery of the year?

It's a tie between Vaughan's Ex Machina with its clever combination of politics and geekdom, and the recently marathoned Merlin.

8. Your biggest fandom disappointment of the year?

Not the BSG finale, which I was mostly okay with, but the previous storyline, or lack of same, for Laura Roslin post Revelations. There were other problems for me in the last half of s4, too (along with elements I appreciated and enjoyed), but Roslin going after three and a half years as one of the best female (or for that matter, of either gender) characters on tv to Bill Adama's love interest is something I will never completely get over with. Despite reaching a sort of zen state via fanfic.

9. Your TV boyfriend of the year?

The aforementioned Star Trek movie triggered a rewatching of not TOS but TNG for me, which put me in Captain, my Captain mood about Jean-Luc Picard all over again.

10. Your TV girlfriend of the year?

Either Gwen Cooper (Torchwood) or Debra Morgan (Dexter). I went from being mostly indifferent to Gwen in the first season of TW to liking her in the second, with the teaser for Something Borrowed mid-season being the point where the sympathy was transformed in love, to absolutely adoring her in Children of Earth. Which means Gwen bashing now makes me even more furious than it used to when I just objected out of general principle. With Deb, I liked her from the get go, but didn't immediately love her. By now, I do, passionately so. She's had fantastic and consistent character development over four seasons, and is probably the character about whom I mostly want to know what she does next.

11. Your biggest squee moment of the year?

Scotty mentions he tried out transportation on a moving object with "Admiral Archer's Beagle". For some reason, this example of the one of the trekkiest of ST inside jokes ever made me laugh and beam so widely my face hurt. Closely matched when the Muller sphere, invented by Milo Rambaldi, found its way from the Alias to the STverse. Oh, J.J. Abrams, you may be on crack sometimes (sometimes?), but I am rather fond of you when you pull these kind of stunts.

12. The most missed of your old fandoms?

Every now and then I think about theatrical_muse, and all the intense and fantastic role play I experienced there with some wonderful fannish writers, and feel both nostalgic and very guilty for leaving. But it was both a time issue and an issue of my muses not talking to me anymore, so I really had no choice.

13. The fandom you haven't tried yet, but want to?

Slings and Arrows.

14. Your biggest fan anticipations for the New Year?

Getting my Hamlet dvd and watching the production I saw live again, the new and final season of Lost, and Iron Man II.
Before I get to the review part of this entry, some other things:

1.) I listened to the audio commentary for ST XI by J.J. Abrams, Alex Kurtzman, Roberto Orci and Damon Lindelof. Highlights:

Spoilers are still giggling )

2.) Apparantly John Simm went all fanboy about David Tennant in DWM 416, swearing, among other things, eternal masterly fidelity ("David is my Doctor"). Quite right, too; I think if and when they bring the Master back for future incarnations, whether for Eleven or subsequent Doctors, he should mirror/contrast that particular Doctor and be played by a different actor. IMO John Nathan-Turner did Anthony Ainley no favours by giving his Master Roger Delgado's look. Different incarnations of the Master should be as different as different incarnations of the Doctor are. One of the reasons why Simm!Master works so well for me is how he specifically mirrors the Tenth Doctor.

3.) Fanfic recs:

Being Human: Everything arrives at the light is a lovely, lovely OT3 friendship story about George, Annie and Mitchell. No spoilers.

Astonishing X-Men: Gravity. Covering the transition period between Joss Whedon's run and Warren Ellis' for my favourite couple, Hank McCoy and Abigail Brand, from Hank's pov. I love this story quite a lot.

Which brings me to:

4.) Review!

S.W.O.R.D. #2 )
Five canon moments that turned a casual fandom into a hardcore fandom for you.

1.) Star Trek: The Next Generation: actually, there are three candidates here, but the last one settled my fate, moving from a TOS-but-willing-to-give-the-new-guys-a-chance to ZOMG!TNG!Fan. The first season of TNG was, err, extremely uneven. The second season had several episodes I liked quite a lot, notably Measure of a Man and Q Who, but I was not yet won completely over. Though scenes like the is-Data-a-toaster debates or Q and Picard in a shuttle certainly helped the process along. Then, however, came season 3 and the episode Sarek. And with it, in addition to a great mix of nostalgia and present day characterness, the scene where Picard channels Sarek's unfettered emotions. Let me tell you, I was glued. And from this point onwards watched every single TNG episode.

2.) Sandman: Neil Gaiman famously remarked that he was still experimenting in Preludes and Nocturnes and didn't really find his narrative voice until issue #8, i.e. the epilogue of the first Sandman trade volume, which introduces Death. This sibling encounter between Dream and Death is what did it for me, too. Until then, I wasn't sure I would continue reading; then, I knew. (In addition to making me a Sandman fan, it made me a Neil Gaiman fan, as it turned out.) Death in her perkiness and slapping-sense-into-her-brotherness was a perfect counterpoint to Dream, I believed these two as siblings, and at the same time, the mythic part of their nature wasn't neglected; Death keeps taking people through this sequence, and it's at the same time scary and comforting. So yes, it was a fandom, here I come moment.

3.) Buffy the Vampire Slayer: so several Highlander fandom friends kept raving about this show. I watched a few season 1 episodes which were amusing, but I wasn't yet hooked. It all seemed pretty black and white, for starters. Season 2 comes along, and I'm still just a casual watcher, not catching every episode. (Though I did see School Hard, as every fandom friend insisted I should. And while I was suitably entertained by the arrival of Spike and Dru, I didn't become really fannish then, either.) No, the episode which made me into a fan, as in, not missing any more episodes from this point onwards and really caring what became of these people was Lie to Me, specifically Buffy's last scene with Giles. (And of course the story leading up to it; Buffy's old friend Ford was until that point the most shades-of-grey villain the show had offered.) To this day, Buffy's last word - "liar" - remains one of the crucial BTVS moments for me. From this point onwards, the show would grow into something fantastically layered.

4.) Angel the Series:: I was mildly curious about the spin-off, especially since Cordelia, who by season 3 of BTVS had become a firm favourite for me, was going to be in it, but I wasn't sure whether Angel himself would be able to carry a series. Angelus aside, BTVS hadn't really presented him as more as Buffy's brooding love interest, plus I had seen Forever Knight. Did there really need to be another vampire detective? So I didn't yet know whether or not I'd watch until the point about 10 minutes into the pilot where Angel, in pursuit of the villain of the day (or rather, night), heroically jumps into the wrong car. (Which sort of cancels the heroic pursuit.) This simple gag not only reassured me the spin-off would have a sense of humour, but also that, by the way he reacted, that Angel did. So this was when I knew I would watch more than the pilot.
4b) AtS when I went from liking to loving: the end scene of Expecting, actually. I was in the very tiny minority of people who had liked Wesley in season 3 of BTVS and who reacted to the news he'd be back in AtS with joy. (*cue Selena's usual "I liked Wes before he became fashionable and when he became fashionable, I didn't like him quite so much anymore" snobbery.*) That last scene, when Wesley is about to leave but desperately wants to stay, and Angel and Cordelia invite him to share breakfeast, made me feel all fuzzy and glowy inside. I think, looking back, the Angel-Cordy-Wes dynamic from the second half of season 1 is my favourite AtS team relationship and -constellation. (Though in terms of storytelling quality and favourite characters, I like later seasons better.) And that was when it came together.

5.) Battlestar Galactica: near the end of the miniseries that serves as a pilot as well, Laura Roslin, secretary-of-education gone president, has a showdown with William Adama. In which she tells him that fighting heroic last stands is really stupid when you have the survival of what's left of humanity at stake, and instead they should hightail it out of Dodge. And he listens. I had seen the pilot and the Pegasus episode of the original BSG, and it hadn't exactly captured my attention; second rate Star Wars, I thought. (And SW hadn't exactly captured my attention the first time around, either, not until ESB really.) Basically the only reason why I watched this new version was that Ron Moore, whom due to his work on both TNG and DS9 - which hadn't been that long ago at that point - I was majorly impressed with, had written it. I found the mini captivating and full of iinteresting elements, plus I loved Roslin pretty much from the get go, but this scene was what settled it for me and pushed it into "awesome! Sign me on! I'll so watch this show!" territory. (And yes, I'm pretty much sighing at the thought of a certain 4.5 storyline now.)
Odd thought of the day: does Galaxy Quest count as the film version of a roman a clef? Because much as Primary Colors was obviously inspired by Clinton and American Wife by Laura Bush, Galaxy Quest doesn't just reference Star Trek (with some other sci fi thrown in as well). The early section, with the actors making the rounds in the convention circuits and the hostile relationships between them and their former leading man is instantly recognizable as specifically the TOS crew and William Shatner, if you've read any of the memoirs by people other than Shatner and Nimoy.

Of course, in Galaxy Quest by the end we've arrived at a new "he's an egomaniac but we love him anyway" status quo, whereas in real life, not so much. Though the reactions among the supporting cast aren't uniform. You have loathing from the start (Jimmy Doohan), first dislike, then loathing (George Takei), first sympathy and admiration, then indignation and dislike (Nichelle Nichols), and exasparation mellowing in a mixture of pity and amusement (Walter Koenig). Incidentally, I've always found the supporting cast's memoirs to be the most readable, not because of the common "Bill Shatner is a bastard" theme but because these people had interesting lives beyond Star Trek. In the case of Nichols and Takei, you get a perspective of what it meant to be an actor of colour in the Hollywood of the 60s. One of my favourite stories comes when Nichelle Nichols describes the filming of Porgy and Bess (directed by Otto Preminger), where she had a small part.

"Fed up with Preminger's condescending attitude toward everyone in the all-Black cast, Sidney Poitier called a full cast meeting. He carefully planned it for a time when Dorothy Dandridge was noton the set. She was a delicate, beautiful woman who deserved far better treatment than Preminger (who had an affair with her) gave her, and Sidney didn't want to cause her further problems with our director.
As Priminger stood there baffled, Sidney expressed his annoyance in no uncertain terms. "Otto! We are not Stepin Fetchits. We are artists!" he roared. "And we will not tolerate your bullying white slavemaster tactics!"
"Hear! Hear!" Brock Peters growled.
"You do not listen, Otto," Sammy added, somewhat more gently. "Otto, baby, you gotta listen, man."
Surprisingly, Preminger did listen without arguing. But to make certain that he fully understood the problem, Pearlie Mae settled it once and for all.
"Look, Otto, honey," she began. "There ain't no use going through this over and over. You've got professional people here, from the stars to the singers and dancers, even the extras. We know our business and we're all working hard, but you are not giving us the respect that is due us. And the way you're treating that poor child Dandridge is disgusting, with her her breaking down every day in tears and holding up production. You better figure this out, honey: we are human beings, not slaves! If you don't, you ain't gonna have no picture."
"Miss Bailey, what do you want from me?" Preminger finally asked.
Pearlie May's eyes narrowed. "Darlign, I know you ain't stupid, and I know you know what respect is. But just in case, I'll tell you. You can start with this damned script. It's written by some silly-ass white boy who's trying to write colored. It's insulting. First, he's written all these "dees" and "dems" and "dose" and "Ises" and "weeses" and "beeses". Well, we've tried to act this dumb crap, but it's all ridiculous. Besides," she added, chuckling, "they're all in the wrong places!"
"What do you suggest, Pearl?" Preminger asked, truly befuddled.
"Honey, just let them write the script in plain English without your white version," she replied. Lapsing into a stereotypical Southern dialect, she quipped, "Wese knows where dem deses and doses and 'i's 'sposed to beses, Mr. Charlie. We don't need no white boy tellin' us how to be cullud...suh!"

George Takei spent part of his childhood in the camps for Japanese-Americans during World War II (Rowher and Tule Lake), which among other things ensured a life long interest and engagement in politics. He campaigned for and was friend with first councilman, then Los Angeles mayor Tom Bradley (the first black mayor in a major American city) and ran for office at the Los Angeles City Council himself. The passage where he explains what playing Sulu meant for him is typical for the larger-context-awareness of his book:

"Throughout our theatrical history, Asians had been visible on American stages and screens from the time immigrants first becan arriving from Asia over a hundred and fifty years ago. In times of prosperity, the depiction of Asians had been benign - usually as quaintly charming or romantically exotic. IN times of stress - of economic hard times and social tensions - Asians and other minorities became scapegoats. The images became darker, depraved, dangerous. Chinatowns were transformed from quartrs of captivating exotica to ominous places of white slavery and opium dens. Quiet, servile Japanese became inscrutable and shifty. At tiomes of war, with Japan, with Korea, or in China, Asians were transformed into deadly omnipotent foes - the personifications of evil. The images of Asians were reduced to politically incited, media-manipulated stereotypes.
We were again engaged in a hot war in Asia. Vietnam was raging. Every night on the six o' clock news, we saw the enemy - deadly, black-pajamana-clad threats in the jungle. It was kill or be killed. These cunning foes had to be destroyed. Bomb them! Burn them! Napalm them!! They had to be wiped out. These enemies in black pajamas... looked like me.
But every night, a little bit after the six o'clock news, the Star Trek reruns came on. There on the bridge of the Starship Enterprise we saw our heroes, the good guys. And there at the helm console we saw Lieutenant Sulu, a crack professional, a swashbuckler, one of our good guys - one of us. ANd he was Asian; his face looked like that of those wearing the black pajamas on the six o'clock news. For the first time in the history of the American media at a time of war in Asia, there was a regularly visible counterbalance to the pervasive image of Asians as evil, of Asians as nemeses. Sulu was on "our side", he was one of the heroes. And his face was mine."

As far as Star Trek is concerned: what everyone's books agree are that DeForrest Kelley was a sweetheart and the nicest guy imaginable, Leonard Nimoy was remote but impressive (and came through for the supporting cast by insisting they should voice their characters in the ST cartoons instead, as the network had originally planned, being replaced by other actors while only the trio was kept, which made a difference to everyone's income)... and, err, that Bill Shatner was something else. Not coincidentally, by the time the books get to Wratch of Khan there is very pointed Ricardo Montalban praise, along the lines of "and then we saw it was possible to be a star and not be an asshole at the same time", or, as Takei puts it: "Ricardo felt he was there to serve the script. If an angle that favored another actor made sense, he deferred. If a scene needed to be tightened and his line of dialogue was slowing the action, he considered eliminating it. (...) Walter, who had many scenes with him, would come off the set marvelling. 'I can't believe it. Ricardo Montalban, this legendary star, is so generous! He's incredible!' Ricardo was a big star in every sense. THere was size to his presence. There was grandiloquence in his speech. And ther was bigness in his spirit."

Walter Koenig, the only one of the TOS supporting cast for whom lightning struck twice, so to speak (i.e. he became part of another cult tv show, Babylon 5), is probably the most self-critical of all the TOS memoirs writers - his memoirs read a bit like an early Woody Allen movie, Koenig as the entertainingly kvetching narrator - , which also contributes to the conciliatory tone towards William Shatner. Case in point, the description of shooting Generations, with which I shall conclude my overview:

"I braced myself the first time Carson offered an alternative approach to ta scene Bill had been rehearsing. (...) Shatner had no problem trying it a different way and brought to his lines the same dedication he ahd done previously. It didn't require great insight on my part to see what was happening. He admitted to me that for the first time he didn't feel like the star of the production. Not carrying all that baggage did wonders for his sense of proportion. He was much more a regular guy than I had ever seen him before.
In the absence of Leonard and De he also turned to me for the small talk around the set. I kidded him a lot. Particularly in his efforts to establish some kind of rapport with Jimmy Doohan. Jimmy was always professional but remained distant. Jimmy has spoken a thousand times about his differences with BIll Shatner. He wasn't about to have a change of heart now.
Now I'm going to relate a story with a one word punchline. THe reader might well wonder why I have included such an apparently innocuous incident here. Innocuous to you, maybe. To me it was historic. We were setting up the scene just after I introduce Sulu's daughter to Captain Kirk. We are both standing on the bridge, the Captain above and slightly behind Chekov, as we watch the young woman move away. The camera is facing us. 'I vas neverr dot young," says the wistful Russian. We rehearsed it a couple of times looking out past the camera, as was natural. Then Bill quietly suggested that, instead, I turn to him while saying the line. It doesn't take Ansel Adams to figure out that if I do that my back is to the lens and there is only one face in the shot.
"No," I said. I can't ever remember saying "no" to Mr. Shatner before. That it took twenty seven years and was such a big deal to me probably says more about my character flaws than his."
Fannish5: Name five characters who would throw the best holiday gatherings.

1.) Londo Mollari, of Babylon 5. Not just because the Centauri in general and Londo in particular love to party, but because Londo actually has organizational skills if he wants to employ them (see: organizing conspiracies against heads of state, getting various representatives of the league of non-alligned worlds he previously pissed off to form an alliance). And he's got the charm and vitality to make everyone feel welcome. Lastly, we have on screen canon for this. I ask you, whose "practice of religious belief" looked like it was the most fun to attend in Parliament of Dreams?

2.) Jadzia Dax, of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine.. Dax loves a party, is tight with the local provider of drinks and food, and with her xenophilia is bound to pick up a rich variety of guests. Centuries of age also give her the knowledge to avoid stepping on anyone's cultural toes. Lastly, I say again, on screen evidence. Her hen night looked like it was glorious fun.

3.) Chiana, of Farscape. Much younger and more anarchic than my previous two examples, but when she wants to say thank you to people she cares about, she has given on screen evidence for her ability to organize a touching celebration (and the food that goes with it). Also, if Chiana is throwing the gathering, you can bet the romantic angst will be kept at a minimum and the fun level will be high; of course, it's not guaranteed all the food was legaly obtained, but in the Unchartered Territories, who cares?

4.) Hugo "Hurley" Reyes, of Lost. This man has proven himself able to throw a party even under adverse conditions on the proverbial desert island, and to cajole people who constantly clash to attend. He's been known to share chocolate even with messed up sociopathic masterminds. Hurley is definitely a candidate for best holiday gatherer ether!

5. Lorne, of Angel. A long time owner of a karaoke bar frequented by demons and humans alike, superb singer, all time nice guy and friend, Lorne probably could throw holiday gatherings in his sleep. (Why, he could organize merry get togethers even in a brain washed state when most of California was temporarily in the Hyperion worshipping Jasmine.) In addition to sharing the celebratory spirit and organizing skills of my previous candidates, Lorne can also provide great music for the occasion. Just be careful not to sing yourself if you don't want advice for what awaits you.
****


Speaking of Chiana,one of the many virtues of the AO3 is that one can discover stories one missed the first time around. I've always had a soft spot for the Chiana-John Crichton relationship, so I was delighted to find a long and plotty adventure starring the two of them:
Left Behind, set in season 3, with the episode Eat Me as a starting point. If you, like me, didn't know this story since ages, go and read at once!

*****

And lastly, one does not need new reasons to love Patrick Stewart, but I found his impassioned article about domestic violence very moving, and very worth reading.
The local supermarket had the last two TNG movies, Star Trek: Insurrection and Star Trek: Nemesis as a special cheap offer, and thus I saw them again for the first time since the cinematic release. (Because they were not exactly good, and I say that as a devoted later series of ST fan, I never made any attempt to rewatch before.)

So, how do they feel several years hence? For starters, there are worse ST movies. (Step forwards, Slow Motion Picture and Final Frontier.) However, the basic problems remained the same. Let's start with Insurrection.

Star Trek: Insurrection )

On to the last TNG movie, object of much fannish ire.

Star Trek: Nemesis )
Transferring Heroes stories to the AO3 was upsetting. I did some choosing and picking, as I didn't want to transfer all, but this meant rereading, which meant remembering, which meant me going "Damn it, Heroes, damn it!".

You know, I've been wondering retrospectively what could have saved the show because it did have such a lot of potential. Realistically saved, which means wishing a completely different mindset on Tim Kring & Co. or completely different writers is out. And my conclusion is that the only plausible option I can see would have been if Kring had stuck to his original idea of introducing a new ensemble cast each season. This would have meant his weaknesses - good long term character development, plausible long term arcs - would not have been exposed, his strengths - origin stories, setting up interesting relationships - would have been played to, and while one season long arcs still could have included problematic choices re: storylines for pocs and/or women, the odds of this being balanced by successful storylines for same would have been higher.

On to more joyful fannish nostalgia, this one concerning Star Trek: yesterday I had tea with an actor who does a lot of dubbing work and was friends with the late G.G. Hoffman, who used to dub both Sean Connery and William Shatner. Hoffmann also supervised a lot of the dubbing for TOS back in the day. And my new accquaintance (who dubbed the occasional Klingon and other guest characters) had an anecdote about visiting Hoffmann once in the studio, finding several female visitors who were ST fangirls (well, -women, that was what struck him, as he had the usual preconceptions about who likes Sci-Fi) who while being intrigued and impressed by the whole dubbing process immediately switched to stern and merciless once the work started whenever Hoffmann made a continuity mistake. They were his continuity advisors, and the actors were all amazed by all the details the fan women knew by their hearts. And took every suggestion...
With the usual caveat that one woman's source of fannish annoyance may be another sentient being's source of fannish pleasure, etc.

1.) Chakotay from Star Trek: Voyager.
Why is he annoying? Spoilers for ST: Voyager ensue. )

2.) Lorien from Babylon 5.
Why is he annoying? Spoilers for Babylon 5 ensue. )

3.) William "Bill" Adama from Battlestar Galactica.
Why is he annoying? Spoilers for Battlestar Galactica ensue. )

4.) Galen from Crusade.
Why is he annoying? Spoilers for Crusade ensue. )

5.) Lila from Dexter.
Why is she annoying? Spoilers for Dexter ensue. )
Choose ten characters. What fandoms would they participate in, and in what ways?

1.) I already did a post on clearly both movieverse Magneto and Xavier being Doctor Who fans, complete with highly scientific poll as to which Doctors and which Companions they like best. Expanding on that, I'd say Erik Lehnsherr to this day argues Genesis of the Daleks with Charles online and and has dispatched Mystique to Simbabe to investigate those rumours that there are copies of the lost Second Doctor episodes there. He could only sell her on this by telling her she might as well kill Mugabe while she was in the country, but by all means had to retrieve the tapes.

2.) Severus Snape, growing up with a Muggle father as he did, had off course access to 70s and early 80s tv. You know what this means, don't you? Young Severus was a Blake's 7 fan. Only Lily knew, of course, because he'd never have confessed it to his Slytherin friends; he just used Avon's one liners to great effect without them recognizing the origin. He used to write Avon/Cally fanfic under a pseudonym for fanzines and then broke it off. During his time as a Death Eater, he was severely tempted to go after Chris Boucher for Gauda Prime, but the thought of Voldemort figuring out the reason held him back. Later, at Hogwarts, he came around to regarding Blake as a great finale. At least Avon didn't have to teach kids as a punishment.

3.) Arvin Sloane's secret vice, as opposed to the more obvious ones, are Andrew Llyod Webber musicals, especially The Phantom of the Opera. He has all kinds of recordings, went to see it every time he was in London for an Alliance meeting and when really depressed finds reading Erik/Christine OTP fanfic complete with Raoul bashing cheers him up to no end. He'd never write it, though. On the other hand, he nearly got into a flame war on the subject why older manipulative mentor types with a killing record might not be the ideal partner for young talented ingenues. The other person just couldn't see Erik did it all for Christine's own good and that she'd never become such a stellar soprano without him; and why should the occasional posing as her father be a bad thing?

4.) Darla was really into Wilkie Collins novels back in the 19th century and had a bet running with Angelus as to what the nature of Sir Percy's secret was, though her favourite of his novels wasn't The Woman in White, it was Armadale. In the 20th century, she discovered the film Theatre of Blood and thought it was a marvellous idea, very inspirational. Only instead of killing off critics by staging Shakespearean deaths, she celebrated her ongoing Collins fannishness by killing off critics who insisted that he just wrote cheap potboilers by staging Collins murders. Also prevented murders which really should have been allowed to succeed for everyone's good, like the death of blond Alan in Armadale, oh yes. Wilkie Collins' reputation with literature professors improved; his critics literally died away. Clearly, fandom is not powerless.

5.) Alex Drake was a big Professionals fan as a girl, read Bodie/Doyle slashfic though she didn't write it, and made character and relationship soundmixes. She also catches Martin Shaw on stage when she can. Well, she did when she was living in the present, that is. Since her trip to the past, she found she couldn't stand watching The Professionals on screen anymore, for some reason, and instead distracts herself by watching Dallas, annoying her teammates by predicting plot twists and reconciling them by inventing drinking games.

6.) Toshiko Sato was a big Battlestar Galactica (new) fan, creating some of the best vids in fandom and writing lengthy, thoughtful meta. She was secretly a Kara/Leoben shipper (secretely because she knew how screwed up that was, and so used another handle when talking about that ship), but her vids were either Roslin-centric or ensemble. She was tempted to ask Jack about the Final Five and how it all ended but in the end didn't, and died not knowing.

7.) Abigail Brand is familiar enough with Star Wars to get Hank's references and respond accordingly, but she's really a fan of the Alien franchise. Ripley was and is her idol. She has all editions of all four movies on dvd and Sigourney Weaver's autograph, though she claimed her geeky boyfriend wanted it. In her non-existant spare time, she writes furious posts in online forums as to why there shouldn't be a fifth one.

8.) John Connor actually tries to stay away from sci fi, but one day caught a BSG episode, and, well, it all ended with him arguing in Television Without Pity why Cylons were completely implausible but Boomer was screwed over as a character anyway and should have gotten a redemption arc. He'd never tell his mother but has a feeling Cameron knows.

9.) Martha Jones stays away from medical shows except House; she and Tom regularly mock the medicine during episodes, but they never miss one, and though Hugh Laurie's American accent still occasionally weirds her out - after all, she watched Blackadder as a girl - she has a huge crush on him. Sometimes she checks the internet for Shakespeare fanfic and never knows whether she's dissapointed or relieved that there don't appear any Shakespeare/Dark Lady stories available.

10.) Vince Matsuka is a big Star Trek fan, which isn't a secret, and mods a Kira/Odo shipping community, which is, since he always tells everyone he's just in it for the chance to get naked photos of the female actors. He also gets into regular flame wars with Kira/Dukat shippers and with someone with a goverment computer IP who wants the discussion to get back to whether the Enterprise could beat the Death Star, with the online handle of LemonLymon.
Ellen by Nyuszi
( Oct. 8th, 2009 04:40 pm)
As the pan-fandom women 40 and over ficathon appears to be wrapped up, here is a list of (some) of my favourite stories. In truth, I thought the overall quality was excellent, and I hope [profile] alara_r will host this ficathon again next year.

Babylon 5:

Desiderata: Timov in her terse, no-nonsense glory, with a sharp eye towards what it means to be a woman in a society such as the Centauri.

Battlestar Galactica:

What's past is prologue: Ellen before, to put it as unspoilery as possible if you haven't finished watching the show. I love how the author creates differences due to the different situation and keeps ongoing traits.

Blake's 7:

Motherhood: Servalan on Gauda Prime. A short and excellent portrait of my favourite evil overlady.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer:

Vigil in Accustomed Places: there were several good stories portraying Joyce Summers in this ficathon, but this one remains my favourite. Oh, Joyce.

Doctor Who:

Writing History: Evelyn Smythe, an (audio) companion of the Sixth Doctor's, has until the broadcast of Waters of Mars the honor of being the physically oldest female companion in the Whoverse (she's 60 when they meet; I know Romana is over 200, but Romana doesn't have problems running in her youthful bodies, does she?), historian by profession, not to be trifled with, and I love her quite a lot. This portrait captures her very well.

And another one for good luck: Barbara Wright, married Chesterton, was a part of the very first team TARDIS back in 1962, all around awesome woman, and largely responsible for transforming the Doctor from a traveller into a hero to begin with. Here she is in the New Who era, still gloriously herself.

Escape: You just know the Rani would have found a way to survive the Time War. Here's one version.

Farscape:

Glue: Noranti always struck me as one of Terry Prattchet's witches on leave from Discworld in the Uncharted Territories. One crone you underestimate at your peril, and this vignette captures both her whimsy and her strength.

Star Trek:

Loving the Alien: Lwaxana Troi was one "love or hate" character in ST fandom. I was firmly on the "love" side of the divide, on both TNG and DS9, and having paid tribute to her in fiction myself some years ago, I always regretted she didn't show up more. So I was delighted to see [profile] alara_r tackle her, and come up with this layered, fascinating result!

Haunted by Geography: fun as the most recent ST movie was, the women, Uhura aside, really suffered from lack of screen time there. Which is where fanfic comes in; [profile] penknife gives us a rich double portrait of Winona Kirk and Amanda Grayson, and they both both shine.

Twin Peaks:

I'll take a quiet life: Twin Peaks was a show where the veneer of cheerful normality covered some incredibly dark messes, and this portrait Norma Jennings in her determined optimism, literally covering up her bruises, captures this beautifully.
Name your five favorite fictional kids.

1.) Addie from Paper Moon. Played by Tatum O'Neal when she was eight years old. Catch phrase: "You still owe me 200 dollars. Paper Moon, a comedy shot in nostalgic black and white by Peter Bogdanovich, is one of my favourite movies, and Addie with her sceptical stare, ability to con people even better than Moses (Ryan O'Neal) and her eye on the cash box is a big reason why.

2.) Nog from Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. Nog starts as a bit part in s1 - Quark's nephew, someone for Jake to interact with - and gradually becomes one of the most important recurring characters who given the sheer number of scenes he had might as well have been a title credits featured regular. His arc from small time thief to first Ferengi in Starfleet to battle-scared young veteran is great; all the more so because while he was industrious, he was never too good to be true, or lost his own cultural background (Nog could quote the Rules of Aquisition just as well as Quark if it suited him), and the subversiveness of the Ferengi child making it big in Starfleet while the Starfleet brat chooses the civilian bohemian route was delightful, as was the Jake-Nog friendship in general. (More in a second when I get to Jake.) We saw Nog grow up on the show, and by the time the seventh season rolled along, he was the subject of one of the most touching episodes dealing with the personal fallout of the Dominion War, It's only a paper moon. (In which Nog deals, or tries not to, with the loss of his leg.)

3.) Jake Sisko from Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. Jake, like Nog, was a realistic teenager, good in his chosen field (writing, in his case) but not on a genius level, which prevented him being hated like Wesley Crusher was. Jake was also the first offspring of a Starfleet officer we were introduced to who had no ambition whatsover to end up in Starfleet himself, and this did not change throughout the show, nor did the show imply that it should, thereby making a great case for civilian pursuits being just as nifty. (The one episode dealing with a future where Jake has given up being a writer presents this as exactly the wrong thing to have done, albeit for a touching reason.) Jake and Nog together were fun, Jake and his father, station commander Benjamin Sisko, have the honour of being the first harmonious father/son relationship being presented in a Star Trek show or movie, and Jake was the focus of two great character episodes, one of which ends up on most people's "best of DS9" and "best of Star Trek" episodes: The Visitor and ...nor the battle for the strong. While I'm usually more prone to focus on Cardassians and Ferengi in my DS9 fic, I found myself writing two Jake pov stories, and he was a very enjoyable voice to explore.

4.) Molly Walker from Heroes. Molly - and Matt's and Mohinder's relationships with her - was one of my favourite things about the second season, and the way Molly was basically written off the show with these relationships made pretty much non-existant was one of many reasons why I broke up with the show for good in the third season. Like Addie, Molly was a very matter-of-fact little girl who could be something of a smart-ass, but unlike Addie, she had also the serial killer from hell murdering her parents in one season and a telepathic psychopath menace her in the other, and she dealt with both in an appealing mixture of realistic fear and bravery. I loved her dearly, and she's the pov character of the Heroes story I'm still proudest of, Dreaming.

5.) Savannah Weaver from Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles. Savannah is one of the highlights of the second season, and the scenes she has with her "mother" Catherine and with the spoilery creature ) are great twists and counterparts to the Connors-Cameron-Reese household as well as being wonderful to watch for their own sake, alternatingly suspenseful, scary, funny and affectionate, or everything at once. Like Molly, Savannah is both realistically scared and brave in the situations she's thrown in, and one of many regrets that cancellation of the show brought was that we won't see her again.

...in not meme related news, I'll be scarce this weekend online, for real life related reasons.
.

Profile

Schreiben by Poisoninjest
selenak

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Layout Credit

Layout:
[personal profile] phoenix