Star Trek: Watergate
Aug. 29th, 2018 10:15 amThe other day I was reminded that one of the unwritten season 7 of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episodes would have been a follow up to season 6’s In the Pale Moonlight, the episode which often (and imo justly) ends up on people’s not just best of DS9, but best of Star Trek lists. Now, according to what I’ve heard, the idea was that Jake, in his capacity as budding journalist, would to his horror uncover what his father (and Garak, and various other people) did to get the Romulans as allies. In the end, TPTB decided not to do the episode because it would have damaged the Ben & Jake relationship, perhaps on a fundamental level, and it being the final season, there would not have been time to rebuild it.
On the one hand, I’m in much sympathy with this argument. The Siskos – both Ben & Jake, and Ben & Joseph – were that rarity in the Star Trek verse (and in US fiction in general), a loving, functional father & son relationship as opposed to the usual daddy issues ridden dysfunctionality. I would not have wanted to destroy this, especially with no time for rebuilding.
On the other hand: it could have been a great story. And it would have been pay-off for Jake’s decision to become a writer and reporter that also tied directly into the main storyline. Also, Sisko’s „I can live with it“ conclusion to In the pale moonlight was depending on no one other than Garak knowing exactly what he’d done. (Quark et all knew some, but not why.) Would he have been able to live with it if the person he loved most in the 'verse would have found out?
( More spoilery talk for In The Pale Moonlight and spoilery polls follow )
On the one hand, I’m in much sympathy with this argument. The Siskos – both Ben & Jake, and Ben & Joseph – were that rarity in the Star Trek verse (and in US fiction in general), a loving, functional father & son relationship as opposed to the usual daddy issues ridden dysfunctionality. I would not have wanted to destroy this, especially with no time for rebuilding.
On the other hand: it could have been a great story. And it would have been pay-off for Jake’s decision to become a writer and reporter that also tied directly into the main storyline. Also, Sisko’s „I can live with it“ conclusion to In the pale moonlight was depending on no one other than Garak knowing exactly what he’d done. (Quark et all knew some, but not why.) Would he have been able to live with it if the person he loved most in the 'verse would have found out?
( More spoilery talk for In The Pale Moonlight and spoilery polls follow )