Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
selenak: (Black Sails by Violateraindrop)
The other day I watched A Dangerous Method again, and, as I wrote in my original review, was frustrated all over again by the sensation of a film having all the right ingredients for me - actors I like (Viggo Mortensen, Michael Fassbender and Keira Knightley), a scriptwriter I like (Christopher Hampton), a director I like (David Cronenberg), complicated relationships, good performances, some excellent dialogue - and yet completely failing to deliver a satisfying whole. I still think the biggest problem is that it focuses on the wrong main character (i.e. Jung), and the second biggest problem that it doesn't overcome its stagebound origins in the way other Hampton adoptions of his plays did. But upon rewatch, other problems occured to me: even within the Jung-as-central-character premise, it avoids digging deeper. Spoilers for not very well known movie ensue. )

So frustrating! But definitely not boring. Also, this time I picked up on more of the musical in jokes. Since Sabina is a Wagner fans, the soundtrack uses a lot of Wagnerian motifs, and the wittiest use is the one of the Valhalla theme at the end of Rheingold , which the movie uses when the skyline of New York comes in sight and Jung is into raptures and says how the Americans are going to love psychoanalysis, which sardonic Freud comments with "before or after they accuse us of spreading the plague?" Given that the splendour of Valhalla at the end of Rheingold is one bought by deception, blackmail and betrayal and also doomed to destruction three operas later, this is very apropos.

In other fannish news: the third season won't be shown for many months more to come, but Black Sails has already been granted a fourth, which makes me a very happy watcher indeed. Also, moving on to another of my fandoms, some great Vanessa Ives icons (from Penny Dreadful).
selenak: (Alex Drake by Renestarko)
Inspiration struck, and now I have a plot idea for my Yuletide story. Not only is this something I haven't explored about these particular characters before - which settles my one concern I had when seeing the prompt: writing them is as comfy as wearing old slippers, but how to avoid following old footsteps? - but I don't think the relevant issue and era has been explored from this angle by fandom in general. Yay!  I'll have to refresh my canon knowledge, but that's not too hard.

In related news, if A dangerous method had been released a month or so earlier I might have included it among my Yuletide requests. It's one of these cases where the source material offers a lot, but ultimately fails to deliver a truly satisfying story, not least because it focuses on the wrong central character.  If you haven't heard about the film, it's an adaption by Christopher Hampton of his play The Talking Cure, directed by David Cronenberg, starring Michael Fassbender as C.G. Jung (this would be the wrong central character), Keira Knightley as Sabina Spielrein (would have been the right central character), and Viggo Mortensen as Sigmund Freud (would also have been a better central character if it wasn't Sabina, especially since this is hands down the best and most entertaining fictional version of Freud I've come across). This is a lot of talent assembled, so the fact there are all the right ingredients and yet no satisfying whole are all the more frustrating.

Read more... )

Profile

selenak: (Default)
selenak

May 2026

S M T W T F S
     12
345 6789
1011121314 1516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31      

Most Popular Tags

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Style Credit

Page generated May. 17th, 2026 02:24 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios