ST: Picard 3.03.
Mar. 3rd, 2023 03:16 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
In which there is a cool twist, and otherwise a mixture of enjoyable and frustrating stuff.
Starting with the bad and ending with the great: see, the problem with Unexpected Children is that you need a good reason why they are unexpected. And our writers here can't come up with a better one for Beverly to keep this secret from not just Picard but all her old friends and to break off relations with all of them than the idea that" as the son of Jean-Luc Picard, Jack would have had a target on his back". Complete with "you told me you have Dad issues" and "you'd never have given up space". I'm sorry, but in-universe, that's rubbish. Firstly, the whole premise of season one was that Picard had left Starfleet and retired to France. I dare say Beverly and Jack were the ones living far more dangerously, if they spent their lives bringing medicine to out of Federation space worlds. So if that had truly been her main reason, she could have told him then. Secondly, 99& of ST characters have parent issues. (The Siskos being the laudable exception.) TNG specific, both Will and Deanna had very big hang ups about their parents. Thirdly, since when endangered being related to Picard anyone? He's not living in the Klingon Empire, is he. When Moore & Braga decided to kill off his brother, nephew and sister-in-law off screen for Generations, they did so via a simple targic accident. And finally, Beverly herself chose a Starfleet career, and even post Starfleet seems to have spend the last 20 years doing dangerous things in space, so seriously, giving an intellegent woman this kind of reasoning is just - a trap the writers made for themselves by going for the Unexpected Kid trope.
(Otoh, I can totally buy Picard and Beverly Crusher had an on/off relationship where they kept switching between romance and friendship and broke up five times because they couldn't get the romance part right and felt more comfortable as friends. That works with the characters and was probably the best part of the scene.)
Moving on to the better stuff: the Raffi and Worf team up so far is excellent. It made me smile that Worf is still into Klingon opera and has updated his introduction from "I am Worf, son of Mogh" (which I found myself mouthing along with him) to "I am Worf, Son of Mogh, of the House of Martok, of the House of Rozshenko", thereby acknowledging all his parents, biological and adopted. And it cracked me up that he assigned himself the part of good cop to Raffi's bad cop when they were interrogating their suspect. Best of all, of course, was the big twist, which makes also sense of Worf having started this investigation: CHANGELINGS! The Great Link having split into a faction Odo is part of and one which wants revenge on the Federation totally works for me, as does Odo contacting Worf, and I'm over the moon we finally have a DS9 main antagonist in the post DS9 Trek. Changelings make an ever so muich better main foe than a lone rogue villain who has it in for either Jack Junior or Picard or both. Not to mention that Changelings as the villains offer a golden opportunity to every one of our actors since they get to play different versions of their characters. And it's not negating Odo's decision at the end of DS9, since the majority of the Great Link is still on his side. It also makes sense that Starfleet for now kees this hush hush and doesn't want a rerun of the Dominion War if it can be avoided. Like I said: excellent plot twist, and I also like both plot threads in the episode, Raffi & Worf on the one hand and the everyone on the Titan on the other, figured out it at the same time. Oh, and Raffi assuming their suspect has drug withdrawal symptoms while Worf recognizes the effect not regenerating for too long has on a Changeling again makes utter sense given their respective backstories.
Picard and Riker: the opening flashback to when Riker has just become a father (of the doomed Thaddeus) which gives the episode its title - 17 Seconds is evidently meant to be mirrored later when Picard like young Dad Riker leaves the bridge when his newborn/hew found son is in lethal danger and in the space between leaving and arriving at sickbay becomes a father, and the actors are good as usual, but alas in the opening scene, the uncanny valley effect of making them look younger is very distracting, and all the forced illogic of Secret Son trope stops me from feeling the later scene. Otoh, what is well build up through the episode is Riker and Picard having different ideas of how to solve the current dilemma and this coming to a head once Riker is in command. (Though I have to say, Will, no one forced you to go for his idea. He didn't override you. So the blame at the end is somewhat unfair.)
Trivia: aaaand we actually get an on screen explanation for Jack's English accent, which is so silly that it's the one thing about this plot twist I didn't mind.
Speculation: okay, with the Changelings as main antagonists, there just has to be a cameo of a DS9 main cast member sooner or later, right? (I mean, other than Worf. Whom I still see as TNG and only holidaying on DS9, despite his bieng there for four seasons.) RIGHT? Who will it be?
Starting with the bad and ending with the great: see, the problem with Unexpected Children is that you need a good reason why they are unexpected. And our writers here can't come up with a better one for Beverly to keep this secret from not just Picard but all her old friends and to break off relations with all of them than the idea that" as the son of Jean-Luc Picard, Jack would have had a target on his back". Complete with "you told me you have Dad issues" and "you'd never have given up space". I'm sorry, but in-universe, that's rubbish. Firstly, the whole premise of season one was that Picard had left Starfleet and retired to France. I dare say Beverly and Jack were the ones living far more dangerously, if they spent their lives bringing medicine to out of Federation space worlds. So if that had truly been her main reason, she could have told him then. Secondly, 99& of ST characters have parent issues. (The Siskos being the laudable exception.) TNG specific, both Will and Deanna had very big hang ups about their parents. Thirdly, since when endangered being related to Picard anyone? He's not living in the Klingon Empire, is he. When Moore & Braga decided to kill off his brother, nephew and sister-in-law off screen for Generations, they did so via a simple targic accident. And finally, Beverly herself chose a Starfleet career, and even post Starfleet seems to have spend the last 20 years doing dangerous things in space, so seriously, giving an intellegent woman this kind of reasoning is just - a trap the writers made for themselves by going for the Unexpected Kid trope.
(Otoh, I can totally buy Picard and Beverly Crusher had an on/off relationship where they kept switching between romance and friendship and broke up five times because they couldn't get the romance part right and felt more comfortable as friends. That works with the characters and was probably the best part of the scene.)
Moving on to the better stuff: the Raffi and Worf team up so far is excellent. It made me smile that Worf is still into Klingon opera and has updated his introduction from "I am Worf, son of Mogh" (which I found myself mouthing along with him) to "I am Worf, Son of Mogh, of the House of Martok, of the House of Rozshenko", thereby acknowledging all his parents, biological and adopted. And it cracked me up that he assigned himself the part of good cop to Raffi's bad cop when they were interrogating their suspect. Best of all, of course, was the big twist, which makes also sense of Worf having started this investigation: CHANGELINGS! The Great Link having split into a faction Odo is part of and one which wants revenge on the Federation totally works for me, as does Odo contacting Worf, and I'm over the moon we finally have a DS9 main antagonist in the post DS9 Trek. Changelings make an ever so muich better main foe than a lone rogue villain who has it in for either Jack Junior or Picard or both. Not to mention that Changelings as the villains offer a golden opportunity to every one of our actors since they get to play different versions of their characters. And it's not negating Odo's decision at the end of DS9, since the majority of the Great Link is still on his side. It also makes sense that Starfleet for now kees this hush hush and doesn't want a rerun of the Dominion War if it can be avoided. Like I said: excellent plot twist, and I also like both plot threads in the episode, Raffi & Worf on the one hand and the everyone on the Titan on the other, figured out it at the same time. Oh, and Raffi assuming their suspect has drug withdrawal symptoms while Worf recognizes the effect not regenerating for too long has on a Changeling again makes utter sense given their respective backstories.
Picard and Riker: the opening flashback to when Riker has just become a father (of the doomed Thaddeus) which gives the episode its title - 17 Seconds is evidently meant to be mirrored later when Picard like young Dad Riker leaves the bridge when his newborn/hew found son is in lethal danger and in the space between leaving and arriving at sickbay becomes a father, and the actors are good as usual, but alas in the opening scene, the uncanny valley effect of making them look younger is very distracting, and all the forced illogic of Secret Son trope stops me from feeling the later scene. Otoh, what is well build up through the episode is Riker and Picard having different ideas of how to solve the current dilemma and this coming to a head once Riker is in command. (Though I have to say, Will, no one forced you to go for his idea. He didn't override you. So the blame at the end is somewhat unfair.)
Trivia: aaaand we actually get an on screen explanation for Jack's English accent, which is so silly that it's the one thing about this plot twist I didn't mind.
Speculation: okay, with the Changelings as main antagonists, there just has to be a cameo of a DS9 main cast member sooner or later, right? (I mean, other than Worf. Whom I still see as TNG and only holidaying on DS9, despite his bieng there for four seasons.) RIGHT? Who will it be?
no subject
Date: 2023-03-03 02:51 pm (UTC)On the other hand if show runners want to make a Worf and Raffi series, I'm there for it.
no subject
Date: 2023-03-03 02:53 pm (UTC)"Worf and Raffi Investigate" does deserve its own miniseries. :)
no subject
Date: 2023-03-03 04:49 pm (UTC)Though Shaw did get a couple of small moments to shine: ordering his own duty bridge crew to get some rest is a very sensible decision and second of course giving Jack the prompt on what the real problem to solve was.
I liked the Crushers helping out in sick bay as well. And the La Forge/Commander Seven scenes. (D'Aww)
I absolutely agree with you that the dominion plot, Worf and Raffi's good cop/bad cop act and Worf's extended son of mogh speech than name drops everyone. (Mogh, Sergei, Martok even Gowron and Duras) are great. Worf's quickly become my favourite here.
Speculation: The worse-than-weapons thing stolen from Daystromm will be Lore.
As for DS9 cameos. I guess O'Brien as another cross series member. But if they followed the Pocket Books/Online game Dax became a Captain. I harbour a faint hope they could have load of starships commanded by DS9/Vgr cameos to serve as last second reinforcements.
no subject
Date: 2023-03-03 04:54 pm (UTC)I don't like the plot line, I agree it makes very little sense but the actors are doing their level best to make a silk purse out that sow's ear I think.
Also just logical sense, I guess future humans have longer lifespans etc can explain it but accidental pregnancy at their age seems.. odd? and if it was possibility weren't you using protection? Ugh.
no subject
Date: 2023-03-04 07:01 am (UTC)You're right about Shaw proving himself by looking out for his crew, the Crushers in sickbay and the LaForge/Seven scenes. I'm looking forward to Geordi himself showing up, which I expect will happen soon - the Daystrom Institute is an obvious place for Raffi and Worf to run into him next.
The worse-than-weapons thing stolen from Daystromm will be Lore.
On the one hand: very likely, given that I doubt they hired Brent Spiner to play yet another member of the Soong family, but otoh, given the later generation and more advanced androids running around freely now post s1, how would Lore be such a threat? I hope there's an explanation.
O'Brien: yes, I could see that. I must admit I'm holding out for Bashir, but that's just personal preference; Kira would make more storytelling sense since a Changeling faction are the antagonists. Otoh, Bashir developed the cure for Odo, which reminds me: I do wonder whether it will be brought up that Starfleet went as far as developing a biological weapon of mass destruction against the Changelings in the Dominion War?
no subject
Date: 2023-03-04 04:00 am (UTC)Aghghg poor Beverly. Poor Gates McFadden.
The Raffi and Worf show sounds great, however! What a neat combo.
no subject
Date: 2023-03-04 07:02 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2023-03-04 07:41 am (UTC)Also, there's a part of me that wishes Worf would have interacted with the late Jadzia in a way similar to the way that he interacted with Raffi, because Worf/Jadzia would have made a lot more sense to me then. Protective? Yes, but not this constant demonstration of controlling and belittling behaviour that we got to see on DS9.
no subject
Date: 2023-03-05 01:38 am (UTC)(There's so much that doesn't make sense. Why wake Beverly up from a medically-induced coma for confirmation of Jack's parentage when they could wave a tricorder at him and know in a moment?)
Picard might be a changeling in the last scene on the bridge (might have been ambushed and replaced on the way back from sickbay) - Riker may have realized that and that's why he sent him from the bridge. Or maybe Riker's a changeling?
I am intrigued by the changeling plot. And Worf and Raffi are terrific! But the Secret Son thing...no, thank you.
no subject
Date: 2023-03-06 02:15 pm (UTC)To be fair, I didn't have the impression this was why they woke her up, but to have more of an explanation as to what was going on - I mean, Beverly said "Trust no one", which requires an explanation more than whatever Jack says, whose biological connection(s) don't mean he's telling the truth about the rest since he's an unknown at this point.
Picard or Riker as a changeling in the last scene: possible. I'm pretty sure we're going to see at least one of them as a changeling at some point in the season, since one of the main points of using the Changelings as antagonists is that they're able to do that. However, I think the switch will happen later, since both were on the bridge when we saw the Changeling with Jack.
no subject
Date: 2023-11-27 11:32 am (UTC)