selenak: (Alex (Being Human)  - Arctic Flower)
2013-02-12 06:05 am

Being Human 5.02

In which we find out more about Alex, and "employees of the month" are never a good idea.

Read more... )
selenak: (Werewolf by khall_stuff)
2013-02-05 08:11 am

Being Human 5.1

If I hadn't decided to let my addictional pic package for lj run out because of all the lj screw ups last year, I'd get me an Alex icon. Welcome back, show!

The Trinity )
selenak: (Avalon by Kathyh)
2013-01-04 06:30 pm

Fannish5: 5 most memorable events in your fandom(s) in 2012

Let's see. Bearing in mind that I'm a multifandom person, here's what comes to mind:

1) Being Human: Spoilers for season 4 ensue. )

2) The Avengers: The Big Damn Superhero Came, Saw And Conquered, managing to unite, as far as fandoms of mine are concerned, my fondness for the Marvelverse in its various incarnations with my interest in the works of Mr. Whedon. I loved every second of it, rewatched it multiple times, devoured a lot of fanfic, but nothing will beat the first, fine, careless rapture of watching it on screen the first time around. What a moment that was!

3) The Hollow Crown: or, the BBC does It's Hard Out There For A Lancaster Richard II, Henry IV 1 and Henry IV II. Verily, it was a good week or three to be a Shakespeare fan. Due to the popularity of Tom Hiddleston, one could even get the reaction of unspoiled fangirls, which, aw, bless. (Though I will admit to feeling, err, somewhat amused at hearing people feel "protective" about Hal, of all the people.) I mean. Hal. Mr. Übercalculating. Much as I cherish the memory of the scene where Hal gets slapped, though, my favourite Hollow Crown moment, and just about every Jeremy Irons scene ever, if I have to pick just one, it would be Patrick Stewart managing to take something which should be completely worn out and sound like nothing but a string of clichés - John of Gaunt's "This England..." speech - and making it sound fresh and alive in Richard II. But then, he is just that awesome.

4) Breaking Bad, season 5: 51. Spoilers for the most recent season of BB ensue. )

5) Merlin, show finale. Once and future spoilers abound. )
selenak: (Branagh by Dear_Prudence)
2012-04-21 03:04 pm

The day before...

The AO3 meme is making the rounds again, and I would do it, except a checking reveals that other than one story, I have the same top ten most read stories as last year on that archive. The one exception: Patterns (Doctor Who) is out, and Five Things Which Never Happened Between Garak And Bashir (DS9) is in. I presume it got linked somewhere. (As it's an older story.) Or it benefited from a general revived interest in all things Trek. Anyway, it and the requivalent Kira & Dukat stories are my favourite examples of how to explore a canon relationship from various angles via AU in my own work, so colour me pleased.

Tomorrow this year's Remix Archive gets opened, and I'm both excited and gearing up to be fannishly angst-ridden. You know, the usual. :) Incidentally, as a reader, if I don't know the original story a remix is inspired by already, it depends on the remix whether or not I read it. If the remix is interesting, I'm curious about the spark, so to speak, but otherwise it tends to be a case of so many stories, so little time. One thing this particular ficathon guarantees is a high percentage of good stories, I've found, some of which completely work on their own, and some who get that extra dimension if you read them as commentary on the orignal and/or the source material. Which may have changed between the time the original story was written and the time the remixer gets to work, and that, too, can influence the second story a lot. I've written two stories this time, one for the regular Remix and one for Remix Madness. Both recognizably me, I think, but since neither has a Beatles song title, one is in a canon I haven't written before and the other in one I love but haven't written often, I'm offering to write a drabble for anyone guessing between tomorrow and reveal day which ones are mine on the subject of their choice.

****

Now I'm still standing by my reasons why as opposed to 90 percent of the fandom, I was distinctly underwhelmed by Loki in Thor and saw him mostly as a gigantic case of adolescent self pity, but none of those were directed against the actor who plays him, Tom Hiddleston, who now has written an absolutely charming article about superhero movies in general. D'awwwwwww. [profile] harmonyangel, this is the article for you!

(BTW: we're getting the Avengers next Thursday. Sometimes being in Europe does mean being ahead instead of behind.)


****

And a Being Human fanfic rec: The Life in a Day, or, one take at those fifty years Leo, Hal and Pearl shared.
selenak: (Werewolf by khall_stuff)
2012-03-26 07:51 pm

Being Human 4.08 The War Child

In which your faithful reviewer does a bad job of fighting the sweetest of temptations.

Read more... )
selenak: (Werewolf by khall_stuff)
2012-03-19 02:07 pm

Being Human 4.07

In which your faithfull reviewer should have seen something coming but didn't and is positively impressed.

Making History )
selenak: (Werewolf by khall_stuff)
2012-03-14 11:51 am

Being Human 4.05

Or, belatedly, by Jove, I got it! And a good thing, too, because now that I've finally been able to watch it in its entirety, I think it's the best episode of the season so far.

What more do you want? )
selenak: (Werewolf by khall_stuff)
2012-03-13 09:08 am

Being Human 4.06 Puppy Love

Unfortunately 4.05 remains beyond my reach after the first thirty or so minutes (I could watch until Yvonne started to show up in Hal's dreams as well), so I can't review it. Colour me frustrated, because until then, I had liked the episode. I also liked this week's, which luckily I could watch without further hindrances.

On to the review! )
selenak: (Redlivia by Monanotlisa)
2012-03-06 03:45 pm

Welcome to my mind

I'd love to review the latest episode of Being Human, but due to CIRCUMSTANCES I haven't been able to watch more than ca. 30 minutes of it. Which was very frustrating to me, especially since I liked the thirty minutes in question. Am still hoping for this to change.

Meanwhle, I'm going through that selfish stage of fannish desire triggered by various upcoming ficathons where I wish the new-to-me shows I discovered in the last half year were more popular and would hence get more fanfic, as opposed to the shows and films I'm just not keen on (or not very), and which have a huge, thriving and writing fandom. Which is to say: I wish people were writing Homeland and Breaking Bad stories in the same amount as Sherlock and Inception fanfic gets written. Also I wonder about insane crossover possibilities, such as:

Homeland/Fringe: an uneasy, tense yet v. v. competent team up for a case between Carrie and Olivia would be awesome. You have CIA versus FBI hostility, and shared common ground of being regarded as an obsessive crazy by your hometeam. Though Olivia after years with Walter Bishop would be able to spot that Carrie actually is both, shall we say, unbalanced, and genius level gifted.

Breaking Bad/Fringe: Walter W. and Walter B. would get on disturbingly well until Walt finds out Walter loves his LSD and his joints by catching Walter in the act with Jesse, which he would find scientifically irresponsible and unprofessional. Meanwhile, Walter would figure out Walt actually reminds him of Walternate.

Breaking Bad/House: I stopped watching House mid s7, so it would have to take place before that, but: through plotty circumstance, Wilson ends up as Walter White's new oncologist. It doesn't take House long to deduce just how Walt earns his living these days, but the idea is so bizarre Wilson refuses to buy it. Meanwhile, Jesse and House's team (any combination of same) commiserate on the trial of working a jerkish genius until Jesse manages to offend Cameron/Thirteen/Martha and they decide Walt's a saint for putting up with him. At which point various druglords and/or their assassins show up afraid that Walt blabbed under the treatment to his oncologist and determined to kill Wilson.

Homeland/Torchwood: post season 1 Brody and Miracle Day era Jack have a one night "I'm still alive/I could die now!" stand after meeting in a bar. Also the MD events confirm Brody in everything he believes. Meanwhile, Esther recruits Carrie.

Breaking Bad/The Good Wife: Saul as the opposing lawyer in Lockhart & Gardner's case of the week, squaring off against Alicia & Diane both. Meanwhile, Kalinda investigates and only the fact Hank is a bit of a racist ass when meeting her prevents the pooling of resources and discovery of the truth about Walt right then and there.
selenak: (Werewolf by khall_stuff)
2012-02-29 08:40 am

Being Human 4.04

You know, I enjoy the current season, but still, it feels like we're back in season 1 territory emotionally and intellectually, which after the narrative heights of season 3 is... weird. It's not necessarily a bad choice and allows you to breathe which s3 did not, but all the same, there's this sense of - well, backslide. I'm trying to decide whether Miracle Day after Children of Earth or season 5 of Angel after season 4 (*waves s4 of AtS was the best* banner as determined as ever*) is the most appropriate comparison.

Also, if your title is a Priestly pun you should have made the story more Priestley-esque )
selenak: (uptonogood - c.elisa)
2012-02-24 06:49 pm

Fannish5: Five characters who are annoying, but that you love anyway.

1.) Gaius Baltar (Battlestar Galactica). He's so many things, but annoying is certainly one of them. (Especially to several of the other characters.) Not all the time, but some of the time. And yet even before it became apparant he had arguably the best individual storyarc of the show, I moved from "like" to love.

2.) Annie (Being Human). She, too, can be annoying at times. Also brave and compassionate, or conversely overlooking the bleeding obvious because of what's going on with her; it contributes to making her very real. Annie is the type of person who'd drive me crazy on a regular basis if she was my friend, but whom I also would go to if I needed a shoulder to cry on, or if I had a moral dilemma to wrestle with.

3.) Rygel (Farscape). Definitely annoying. Also wily, greedy, a great survivor with an iron core of resilience (let's see how you'd do if Durka had a go at you for a few days, never mind years, as in Rygel's case), and surprisingly good with not self interested advice once in a while (ask Aeryn in The Choice, where he was the only character who talked to her for her sake, not because of an own agenda, or John in the season 4 opener, not that John listened, but still). Also the smartest person on the show other than Scorpius according to the producers, and I'm cool with that.

4.) Lwaxana Troi (Star Trek: The Next Generation). I love her to bits, and think she's magnificent, larger than life, full of joie de vivre yet also very much aquainted with grief and loss. Yet I can't deny she can also be annoying. Does this matter to me? No one bit.

5.) Andrew Welles (Buffy the Vampire Slayer). I completely get what fans mean when they call him annoying, starting with the voice and ending with the fact that some of his screentime is spent being a whiny murderer determined to see himself as the maligned hero. On the other hand, he: can coin phrases with the best Sunnydalians ("I'm a guestage"), endearingly never fanboys the obvious favourites (I mean, if you go for Timothy Dalton in your Bonds and Jonathan Archer in your Starfleet Captains, nobody can accuse you of catering to majority opinions!), and is such an unabashed shipper and storyteller. (Also? Spike letting Andrew hug him in front of the amused AtS gang without mocking him or pushing him off, and later answering his questions like what blood actually tastes like is what sold souled Spike to me.) I'm not sure I'd trust more-or-less-redeemed Andrew, but I'd definitely hang out with him. He could bake cookies.
selenak: (Werewolf by khall_stuff)
2012-02-22 11:23 am

Being Human 4.03

If my theory is true, I must somehow make [personal profile] likeadeuce watch this show. If only so she can write the inevitable Shakespearean crossover.

Once more into the breach )
selenak: (Nina by Kathyh)
2012-02-14 06:34 pm

Being Human 4.1 + 4.02

In which having watched several seasons of Spooks as well as the writing level having risen incredibly in s3 of this show turns out to be very helpful to this viewer.

Actually, I did that )
selenak: (Claudius by Pixelbee)
2011-12-26 08:39 pm

Yuletide I

If you're looking for the archive itself to browse at your own leisure, here it is. This is just a first bunch of recs, more to come!

History:

Still Climbing after Knowledge Infinite

In which young Will from Stratford hangs out with a couple of other Elizabethan playwrights, spars and flirts with Kit Marlowe, and figures out his own writing voice. Just delightful.

Todos Los Bienes Del Mundo (1598)

That Philipp II. during his brief time as Mary's husband in England got at least emotionally involved with his sister in law and future arch nemesis, Elizabeth, is a tantalizing possibility brought up now and then in biographies. (Not least because of the apocryphal story that he confessed as much.) Here is old Philipp reflecting on their youth, talking to his best enemy. Very well done, not least because it's believably from the Spanish pov.

American Gods:

The Man in the Gaberdine Suit

In which Shadow returns to America, meets gods old and new, and has a decision to make. Captures the style of the novel really well, and the (surviving) characters.

Being Human:

Passing Bells

A Nina pov, set after the third season, and a terrific character exploration of her and through her of the other characters and their situation. Bonus point for including Tom.

Deadwood:

The Outward Gift

Lovely exploration of the tender, damaged relationship between Joanie Stubbs and Calamity Jane. Awesome use of Charlie Utter as well.

Some Like It Hot:

Scenes from a floating oasis

In which, after the movie, four people on a yacht try to figure out what comes next. A charming ensemble story that showcases the ambiguities in everyone very well.

The Sarah Jane Adventures:

Queens of the Marsh

In which the inevitable happens and Rani meets the Rani as Our Heroes try to solve the latest weirdness, which involves alien frogs. It's the kind of story you can imagine on the show, and everyone is delightfully in character. Clyde's drawing talent is put to good use and Rani shows off her budding journalist skills which pleases me muchly.

Galaxy Quest

Episode Thirty Three: The Dark Reflection

In which Gwen, back in the day, gets the script for the Galaxy Quest version of the Mirrorverse episode and is awesome. I love this both for the way it is pretty realistic about tv writing (sadly not just in the 70s) and yet allows Gwen to play the game better than the sexist she's dealing with. It's funny, acerbic, and leaves you whistling. My head canon now, definitely.
selenak: (Mystique by Supergabbie)
2011-11-26 11:25 am

Fannish 5: Gratitude


5 fandom-related things you are thankful for. 
(Feel free to interpret this however you wish: thankful for a sequel, thankful for no sequel, thankful for a kink meme, thankful character X got a good death, thankful actor Z is going to be in QRS, etc.)

My pleasure. Let's see:

1.) Being Human, season 3.  After feeling so-so about season 1 and being so infuriated by a lot of s2 I was not sure whether or not to continue, season 3 proved to be as amazing an example of unjumping the shark/growing the beard as they come. Consequences got served, relentlessly. Characters I had lost sympathy for regained them (with one exception, and that was part of the seasonal point), characters I already loved were even more awesome while still remaining capable of their own mistakes. In short, season 3 rocked.  And before you ask, yes, I know about the other casting spoiler, and that's regrettable, but we'll always have the amazing season 3.

2. Raven/Mystique in X-Men: First Class. Actually, I'm grateful for the whole film, which despite the flaws revitalized not just my own enthusiasm for the movieverse, but what I'm more grateful for than for any other aspect is Raven,  not least because as opposed to the Charles/Erik slashiness, her part in XMFC was something I had not expected, so from the moment the trailers indicated she would have a major role and that she and Charles met each other as children, I  never stopped being pleasantly surprised.  Not only did her role here took the bad taste out of my mouth her treatment in X3 had left, but the whole finding herself arc plus the sibling relationship with Charles hit several of my favourite narrative kinks. Lastly: the fact she didn't just name herself but Erik and Charles as well will never not make me happy.

3.)  Ficathons, their organizers and participants, not limited to but exemplified by Remix and Yuletide. Without them, a lot of the fannish joy and interaction would be missing, not to mention personal challenges to me as a writer, and I really, really appreciate them.

4.) The Borgias. Thank you, Neil Jordan. It was everything I hoped it would be, full of Renaissance atmosphere, with great performances and beautiful cinematography, using its ensemble instead of wasting it, and above all, had interesting female characters with interesting relationships to each other, not just the men in their lives. 

5.) Feedback even on old stories.  No matter whether it's a short "great story", or a lengthy analysis, I'm pleased as punch everytime someone leaves a comment on one of my stories. ( Excepting the occasional "why did you make William gay?" weirdness.)  It's something specific to the internet age and fannish interaction that I treasure, and when it happens to old stories, it also evokes the glow of nostalgia to boot.
selenak: (Borgias by Andrivete)
2011-04-12 05:59 pm

Links

The Borgias causes that interesting thing, historical fiction that is not yet based on the show (since the events depicted haven't happened there yet) but semi-influenced by it. If you don't mind being spoiled for history (which might or might not happen on the show), check them out!

In disputation: which is Lucrezia at five crucial points in her life.

And you could have it all, my empire of dirt: Cesare at the end.

Two meta recs:

Star Trek: The Next Generation: Jean-Luc Picard meta, which also touches on how Patrick Stewart made TNG real, and the changing ST universe throughout the show's run. I don't agree with all points, but as always, [profile] abigail_n writes so very well.

Being Human: Why Nina and Annie did the right thing. Comes with real life comparison, and makes a point you'd think self-evident, except that given fandom's throughout the second half of the last season, it apparantly was not.
selenak: (Nina by Kathyh)
2011-04-10 10:13 am

Ah well...

Being Human fanfic rec:

The Vampire Lestat Lied To Me (And So Did Edward Cullen) . The content of which can't be described without spoilers for the s3 finale, so I shall hide it under a cut ) Delightful to read, as is this author's wont.

60s anecdote to make you go faceapalm of the day: Bob Dylan's way of responding to being turned down. Quoth Marianne Faithfull:

“Apparently Bob Dylan spent days and days writing a poem for me in 1964 and I think it was understood in his circle that I would go to bed with him. I mean, I presume that’s the intention when you’re a very pretty girl and you go to a big star’s bedroom, isn’t it? But I didn’t realise this at the time because I was just a silly teenager and it was all a bit much. Actually I very much wanted to go to bed with him, but I was pregnant and about to get married [to John Dunbar] at the time. I told him all this and he was furious and ripped the poem up in front of me. We are still very fond of each other and still talk about that night. I’ll always say to him, ‘But Bob, I was only 17’ and he always says, ‘Yeah, but I was only 22 myself!’” The sad thing for me was not that we didn't go to bed together, but that I never got to see that poem."


Now, one could make observations about the sexual standards of the day and/or Dylan's passive-aggressiveness, but what I'd rather ask a question of conscience: would you, dear reader, have had sex with Bob Dylan at age 22 if you got your very own Dylan poem/song out of it?

Unsolved Beatles mystery of the day with theory of solution presented by yours truly:

http://beatlephotoblog.com/photos/2011/03/1164.jpg

What you see here, faithful viewers, is one Paul McCartney with Linda at one side and Denny Laine on the other, in 1975, holding... the John Lennon/Yoko Ono Two Virgins album from 1968 in his hand. (You know, the one with the nude cover and recorded during their first night together.) Now, Paul depicted holdling a new Lennon album would make some sense (they kept an eagle eye on each other's output post break-up at the worst of times, and by 1975 they were on visiting and hanging out with terms again). But Two Virgins? Which wasn't even released in large quantities so that by 1975, you really had to do some detective work to get a hold on a copy? The hell?

Boring solution: a fan gave it to him to sign. Either because the fan had a dark sense of humour or because, well, there is a Paul quote printed on the cover of this John/Yoko event. ("When two great saints meet, it is a humbling experience.")

More interesting solution: May Pang mentions in her memoirs that John had her go to Beatle conventions, specifically tasking her to buy up Two Virgins albums "to get them out of circulation". (This proved fortunate because at the first convention she visited, she encountered John's old Hamburg buddy Jürgen Vollmer who was selling his photos of the young Beatles in Hamburg. Thus Vollmer reestablished contact with John, and his photo of a young John Lennon leaning against a door became the cover of John's Rock'n Roll album.) Never mind fans having a wicked sense of humour, John definitely had one. Do I believe him capable of presenting Paul with one of those out-of-circulation albums? You betcha.
selenak: (Nina by Kathyh)
2011-03-27 11:04 am
Entry tags:

Meta link, and a story of three women

I haven't watched the US version of Being Human, nor do I intent to, but even if you, oh reader, are not familiar with either the British or American one and have no intention of ever watching a single episode of BH, check out this post for a great demonstration of what "the male gaze" means, and how you can film two identical scenes in completely different ways, resulting in very different emotional content. (Err, spoilers for two scenes in the respective first seasons of both shows.) Hint: one is cheap exploitation, and the other is not.
***

A few more pictures under the cut, this time of arguably the people who had it worst in the entire Beatles saga, the three first wives of John, Ringo and George. I'm excepting Jane Asher her, not because she was never married to Paul but because she managed to never let being romantically involved with a Beatle be detrimental to her own life. Being accomplished and famous in her own right as an actress before, during and after the five years they were together undoubtedly helped, as did ignoring any demands to settle down (as opposed to Pattie Boyd, who gave up her modelling career when George asked). As did trying to keep her life with Paul as much separately from Paul's life with the group as was possible. (Jane Asher was and is famously discreet after her break-up with Paul, but the two times she said something on the record during the relationship - in Michael Braun's 1964 book about the Beatles en tour, Love Me Do, and in Hunter Davies' 1968 The Beatles she sounds more critical than any of the Beatle wives/girlfriends has gone on record with being and unequivocably states she has no intention of being "part of a gang".) But the way Cynthia Lennon, Pattie Harrison and Maureen Starkey dealt with the rock star wives life, how they became friends, failed each other and reconciled is a poignant drama of its own. It's a very 60s and early 70s tale from the female side as opposed to the male one.

Wives and Friends )
selenak: (Scarlett by Olde_fashioned)
2011-03-25 08:22 am

(no subject)

Two more Elizabeth Taylor related quotes, one from this obituary:

She was a lovely actress and a better star. She embodied the excesses of Hollywood and she transcended them. In the end, the genius of her career was that she gave the world everything it wanted from a glamorous star, the excitement and drama, the diamonds and gossip, and she did it by refusing to become fame’s martyr.


And, somewhat apropos, here's a description of Elizabeth Taylor in the mid 70s meeting John Lennon, Elton John and David Bowie (whom she introduced to Lennon, with musical results). This could have gone quite wrong (what with John's nasty habit of putting people on pedestals and then kicking the pedestals away when the reality of them did not meet his impossibly high expectations), but it went splendidly. She was the queen, and he was her admiring subject. (Also I am amused that of the three rock stars present, it was Bowie whom she whisked away for a private audience. Good choice, Elizabeth.) John's recapitulating statement on her at the end of this excerpt from his girlfriend May Pang's memoirs, in a way, is the same thing the obituary quoted above says.


John was every excited. "I've never met Elizabeth," he said. "I'm dyin' to go."
The party took place in a lavish Beverly Hills mansion, and there was a large buffet table and a bar. John and I stood in one corner, searching for stars we had never seen in person before. While we looked over the crowd, everyone was busy staring at us. Even though John always liked to meet really famous people, he was still the most famous person in the room. We slowly made our way through the house, chatting with whoever approached us.
"Where's Elizabeth?" John asked. "I want to see Elizabeth."
Forty minutes after we arrived, Elizabeth Taylor sailed into the room. The party stopped dead while everyone turned to stare at her. There was a star! I was surprsed to see how small she was, because everything about her was larger than life. Her hair was teased up in an elaborate hairdo that towered over her head. Her extraordinary violet eyes were lined in thick beads ov violet eyeshadow. She made no concession to her weight and she was costumed in a paneled paisley dress, each panel in a different shade of pink. Around her neck she wore one huge diamond surrounded by a cluster of emeralds. She was dazzling.
Like teenage boys, John and Elton nervously approached her. She beamed when she saw them. "Oh," she said, "I'm so pleased to meet you." John and Elton responded to her genuine delight. They both did their best to amuse her. She laughed merrily at their lines and threw in a number of her own.
When David Bowie arrived, she seized his arm: "David, do you know John?"
"No, but I've always wanted to meet him." Bowie flashed his bright smile at John. There was a look of genuine admiration in his eyes. John, who found Bowie's music fascinating, was very cordial. David had great charm and was also funny. The dialogue began to flow even more quickly.
The group finally broke up, and David announced: "I've got to go. I've got to go." He turned to leave. Later in the evening we found him in deep conversation with Elizabeth Taylor on a couch in a deserted room at the back of the house. John and I stared at them. The screen goddess and the porcelain-faced, orange-haired rock star made a startling-looking couple. Yet, sitting there, gazing into each other's eyes, they seemed to be long-lost friends, sharing their most intimate secrets. "May, John, join us," Elizabeth called out when she spotted us, and we sat down beside them. In a few minutes all of the remaining guests had crowded into the little back room and once again we were surrounded by onlookers.
On the way home John and I talked about how much we had liked Elizabeth Taylor. "She's not rock'n roll," John said. "She's not like us. We get crazy as we get older. She's been trained to deal with things."


****

Being Human fanfic rec: The Opposite of Death, a coda to the s3 finale, near impossible to describe without spoilers. Very much about the three people I wanted to read about, though.


BTVS and AtS vid rec: Some Peace. Buffy, Angel, Darla, Willow, Spike, Faith, Wes, Gunn, Fred, Connor. My Jossverse love is strong, and the vid reminds me why.
selenak: (Nina by Kathyh)
2011-03-20 07:14 am

Two links and a thought about narrative promise

Being Human: two quite different yet both eloquent meta posts:

Being Human, Season 3

Vampires and their cryptic bullshit

Both posts, though their interpretation of some characters wildly differ, say yes to s3 and its arc. It occured to me that one of the objections I've heard elsewhere was that "this isn't the show we were promised in the pilot", which immediately reminded me of one of the calmer Children of Earth criticisms (i.e. that CoE Torchwood was not "the show we were promised" in that it was quite different from the TW of Cyberwoman yore). It's a fair point to raise though I would say the difference between pilot Being Human and the first season is already pointed, and not simply because of the recasting of several roles. Still, I can see that if you basically signed on for a very charming supernatural sitcom, which is what you get in the pilot, then what the show turns into is most definitely not what you "were promised". I'm with [profile] abigail_n in one of the posts linked above, though, that with s3 the show has reached the story it was meant to tell. Of course, I feel that way about Children of Earth as well, so...

It's not that I think "dark" always equals good, by the way, on the contrary. For example, I'd say that parts of BSG's third and most definitely its fourth season drift too much into self indulgent angst for angst's sake territory, as does much of Farscape's fourth season (but not the concluding Peacekeeper Wars mini). But in the cases of season 3 of Being Human, Torchwood: Children of Earth or, for that matter, Angel's season 4 I felt the respective shows had each managed to follow a relentless narrative arc to its logical conclusion, to explore their characters more deeply and cast of (much) of the attributes that I was not on board with before - to tell a story only they could in this particular way.

What it comes down to, I guess, is that I don't mind not getting what "we were promised" if what we do get is something that appeals to me more. For that matter, season one DS9 while having potential is still quite different from later season DS9, and you could make a case that the "promise" of that first season show is most definitely not what it turns into later on. Take one of the goals established in the pilot: Sisko is explicitly told that one of the reasons for the Federation presence on DS9 is to woo Bajor into joining the Federation and to prepare the planet for this. One of the most crucial turning points in s5 is when they're all but set to do this in the season 5 episode Rapture and Sisko interrupts it, advising, declaring Bajor must not join the Federation. There is a larger plot reason for this and it pays off, but by the time the show wraps up in s7 Bajor still isn't a Federation member. Which is one of the things that makes DS9 uniquely DS9 - the way the whole joining the Federation and the Federation itself is problematized*, much of the narrative arcs given to non-Fed regular characters like Kira or Odo. My point is, the show DS9 developed into is narratively much richer and more interesting to me than the one arguably promised in the pilot, and if the pilot promise had been stuck to, it would have been a lesser DS9.

Sometimes you start a story in one direction, and you discover potential leading the story in quite different directions. It doesn't always mean the ensueing narrative is worth the departure. But it can be, and when it does, I am your devoted reader/listener/viewer.


* I have to add here that contrary to popular cliché DS9 was not the first Trek show to feature darker sides of the Federation, but TNG did this only sporadically and embedded in many more "bright side" episodes - Measure of a Man or The Drum Head were hardly setting the tones of their respective seasons. Still, they do exist, years before DS9, and that's why I always resent generalizations about pre-DS9 Trek that pretend they don't.