yhlee asked me this. Well, you know, there's an eas(ier) answer for this, since I'm a Beatles fan. And several of the Beatles' albums were, among other things, movie soundtracks. Of these, pace
Yellow Submarine and
Magical Mystery Tour fans, I certainly would list
A Hard Day's Night,
Help and
Let It Be among my favourite scores of all time. Hard to impossible to choose between these three, as it very much depends on what I'm in the mood for. Note that none of this is about the quality of the respective movies - general consensus, which I don't disagree with, is that
A Hard Day's Night is best on the movie front - but
Help has the title track,
Norwegian Wood,
If I Fell, and oh, yeah, good old Scrambled Eggs, aka
Yesterday, and
Let It Be, even in the Phil Spector'd version, has again the title track,
Don't let me down,
Get Back.... Nah, can't choose.
Excluding the Beatles, but still in the 1960s, there's the score for
The Graduate, which has Simon & Garfunkle on top of their game, with
Mrs. Robinson and
Sound of Silence as the two standouts, but I can't say I remember much of the orchestral music, so it doesn't really count.
Let's go back in time: among the many aspects that are truly great about
Citizen Kane even after decades of cultural hype and backlash is most definitely the soundtrack, which put good old (back then, young) Bernard Herrman on the musical landscape. Like most of the people involved in creating
Citizen Kane, he'd worked with Orson Welles on the radio before, including arranging the music for the infamous
War of the Worlds broadcast, and composing it for various other Welles/Mercury Theatre radio productions, like
Rebecca, and it shows in the best way.
Citizen Kane was in fact his first movie soundtrack, and he pulled it off in great style, and in a great variation of styles, from the forbidding opening "Xanadu" theme to the engaging "Kane takes over the Inquirer" sequence (
here it's conducted by none other than John Williams in a concert performance) to composing a bona fide Meyerbeer style opera aria for Susan to sing (or rather, fail at singing), which afterwards was and is still performed in concert by many a soprano;
here is Kiri Te Kanawa doing the honors. As this is also a score where I love both the music and the movie, it definitely heads my list of non Beatles favourite movie scores.
Now upping the stakes to "score with not one sung word" - which excludes
Kane because of not just the aria but also the "Who's the man?" song from the party scene - I have to move forward in time again, to all the Sergio Leone/Ennio Morricone collaborations. While the soundtrack for
Once upon a time in the West probably objectively speaking is better, my own favourite among these is the one for
Once upon a time in America. I'm only so-so about the movie itself, but I bought the vinyl of the soundtrack back in the day, and the cd was one of the very first cds I bought. So definitely this one, in that category. To this day, when I hear the pan flutes I get wistful and sad.
Moving on to tv: I still think overall
Buffy the Vampire Slayer offered a superb mixture of original instrumental music by Christophe Beck and well selected songs by various artists to go with its episodes, even if you exclude the musical episode (which even many a year and competition later is still my favourite musical episode of a tv show). Beck's masterpiece was probably the score for
Hush, aka the "silent movie" episode, but seriously, it's hard to single out one particular episode beyond that because the soundtrack was consistently good from start to finish, and it's definitely my favourite for tv.
The other days