September 5 (Film Review)
Jan. 28th, 2025 04:00 pmA taut, intense thriller, which got just Oscar-nominated for best original script. Here's crossing my fingers they win, and not just because the co-scriptwriter, Moritz Binder, is a homeboy (i.e. from Munich). (The director, Tim Fehlbaum, is Swiss. The film while being a German coproduction was shot in English as the original language, though.) It's just a superbly crafted movie, and compares favourably to one of the lesser Steven Spielberg movies, to wit, Munich, in which Spielberg tackled the aftermath of the the September 5 events. What both movies also have in common is that they combine the suspense thriller structure with a morality play, in the case of September 5 about personal and professional ethics of the media and in the case of Munich, essentially, about justice versus vengeance and what price vengeance. Spielberg tried to pack in too much, went for the sprawling epic vein, did action sequences in lots of countries and one horribly awkward sex scene (confirming my suspicion he just can't do sex scenes), and ultimately, his movie while not uninteresting failed, and I never had the desire to rewatch. Meanwhile, Fehlbaum essentially has just one location for the entire movie - the small studio ABC used during the 1972 Summer Olympics in Munich -, literally never leaves it, a very small ensemble of characters, all talk and no on screen action (when things start to go horribly wrong, they do so via sound and some footage the main characters watch on their own viewscreens), and succeeds with flying colours.
What it is about, exactly: Our heroes are a small group of US sports journalists (and one (female) German translator) working for ABC and reporting live from Munich in the summer of 1972; these were the first Olympic Games to be broadcast live around the world. (Sidenote: I was a three years old toddler and thus have no personal memories, but my parents, who lived just two hours away from Munich, managed to get tickets for several events and were incredibly excited beforehand. It's had to overestimate what a big deal these Munich Olympics were in German, especially for young people like my parents or the character of Marianne in this movie. Not least because they were meant to showcase a changed Germany and were very much designed to be the exact opposite of the 1936 Berlin Olympics under the Nazis. In 2022, on the occasion of the 50th anniversary, there were commemorative events in Munich through the entire year, both because of the tragedy that ensued and because of the transformation these Olympics achieved beforehand for Munich.)This is a time when all the various broadcasters have to use the same satelite, with prearranged timeslots, cameras were really heavy to carry around, and anything digital is still a futuristic dream. And then, in the early early morning hours of September 5th, gun shots are heard in the Olympic village...
( Spoilers for historic events and the movie ensue )
In conclusion, a film that proves that if you tackle a difficult subject of relatively recent history (and ongoing implications for the present), less is more, and you gain rather than lose in quality.
What it is about, exactly: Our heroes are a small group of US sports journalists (and one (female) German translator) working for ABC and reporting live from Munich in the summer of 1972; these were the first Olympic Games to be broadcast live around the world. (Sidenote: I was a three years old toddler and thus have no personal memories, but my parents, who lived just two hours away from Munich, managed to get tickets for several events and were incredibly excited beforehand. It's had to overestimate what a big deal these Munich Olympics were in German, especially for young people like my parents or the character of Marianne in this movie. Not least because they were meant to showcase a changed Germany and were very much designed to be the exact opposite of the 1936 Berlin Olympics under the Nazis. In 2022, on the occasion of the 50th anniversary, there were commemorative events in Munich through the entire year, both because of the tragedy that ensued and because of the transformation these Olympics achieved beforehand for Munich.)This is a time when all the various broadcasters have to use the same satelite, with prearranged timeslots, cameras were really heavy to carry around, and anything digital is still a futuristic dream. And then, in the early early morning hours of September 5th, gun shots are heard in the Olympic village...
( Spoilers for historic events and the movie ensue )
In conclusion, a film that proves that if you tackle a difficult subject of relatively recent history (and ongoing implications for the present), less is more, and you gain rather than lose in quality.